U20 6N: Three changes to Scotland side ahead of Ireland clash

Head coach Carl Hogg urges youngsters to draw inspiration from the way England Test side approached Irish challenge

Charlie Jupp
Charlie Jupp has moved from the second-row to the back-row for Scotland Under-20s match versus Ireland on Friday night. Image: Fotosport

CARL HOGG has made three personnel changes, plus two positional switches, to the Scotland Under-20s side which lost their Six Nations opener against Italy at Netherdale last Friday night, ahead of facing Ireland at the same venue this coming Friday.

Ewan Ashman comes in at hooker for Finlay Scott, who dislocated his shoulder versus Italy and will take no further part in the campaign; while Cameron Henderson is promoted to the second-row, with Charlie Jupp shifting to blind-side flanker, Kwagga Van Niekirk moving to No 8 and Jack Mann dropping to the bench.

“I see Connor Boyle as an out-and-out seven, and Kwagga gives us that power, and Charlie is probably a modern-day hybrid who can play both second-row and number six, so I think it just gives us a bit more balance in the back-row,” explained Hogg.

Scotland v Ireland: Ryan Wilson on the lessons of England’s Dublin domination

Scotland v Ireland: WP Nel set to miss Ireland clash due to calf tear

Scotland v Italy: Gary Graham finally reaches the promised land

Meanwhile, in the back-line, Ayr’s Ollie Smith, who was unable to train during the first part of the week due to a bruised calf, is replaced at full-back by Rufus McLean of Watsonians, who scored a try off the bench against Italy. “Rufus looked particularly sharp off the bench having been out for a wee while,” said Hogg. “It will be interesting to see him getting up to match speed on Friday night.”

Matt Davidson of London Scottish joins the replacements.

The Italian game was a frustrating experience for the young Scots. They started slowly and gifted their opponents some easy points in the first half, but they flew out the traps after the break to score two well-worked tries which snatched a 17-11 lead, only to let it slip away again through a combination of poor decision-making, poor execution and poor discipline.

Hogg is in no doubt that his side will have to raise their game considerably across the full 80-minutes if they are to get anything out of Friday’s appointment, against an Ireland side which started their Six Nations campaign with an impressive victory over England.

“They’ve got high line-speed, and they like to stay nice and compressed defensively and challenge you round the breakdown,” he said. “We watched their game on Friday night and they look a very competent side with a very intense, suffocating defence and really good basic skills, so we’ll have to be at our best to challenge them.

“But I think there is huge room for improvement for us. You’re never quite sure how much information and how many behaviours from training hold going into a match, but we’ve clearly identified things we can work on and things we can do better, and we’re looking forward to putting that into practice on Friday.

Hogg added that he will be urging his boys to draw inspiration from the way the England senior side countered Ireland’s strengths last Saturday.

“When you look at the [Ireland] Under-20s, you will see a carbon-copy of their Test team – they’ve got very similar traits – and that clearly comes through their youth system,” he said. “They’ve got threats over the ball defensively – all the time, from one to 15 – which is pretty unique. And they’ve got high line-speed. But that does offer opportunities, and I think the English Test team exploited that particularly well last Saturday, so that’s clearly an area we have identified and an area we are looking to challenge.”

Scotland U20 team to face Ireland U20 at Netherdale in the U20 Six Nations on Friday 8 February (kick-off 7.30pm): Rufus McLean (Watsonians); Rory McMichael (Heriot’s), Cameron Anderson (Wasps), Robbie McCallum (Complutense Cisneros), Jack Blain (Heriot’s); Ross Thompson (Glasgow Hawks) VICE-CAPTAIN, Roan Frostwick (Currie Chieftains); Sam Grahamslaw (Leicester Tigers), Ewan Ashman (Sale Sharks), Murphy Walker (Stirling County), Cameron Henderson (Stirling County), Ewan Johnson (Racing 92), Charlie Jupp (Heriot’s), Connor Boyle (Watsonians) CAPTAIN, Kwagga Van Niekirk (Lions). Subs: Angus Fraser (Glasgow Hawks), Andrew Nimmo (Glasgow Hawks), Euan McLaren (Ayr), Ross Bundy (Stirling County), Jack Mann (Edinburgh Accies), Kyle McGhie (Musselburgh), Nathan Chamberlain (Bristol Bears), Mat Davidson (London Scottish).

Club XV: Scotland frustrated and frozen out by ‘gnarly’ Ireland


About David Barnes 3268 Articles
David has worked as a freelance rugby journalist since 2004 covering every level of the game in Scotland for publications including he Herald/Sunday Herald, The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The Scotsman/Scotland on Sunday/Evening News, The Daily Record, The Daily Mail/Mail on Sunday and The Sun.