Super6: Watsonians book a home play-off with comeback win over Heriot’s

Myrside men were 18-points down after half an hour but battled back to secure their seventh win of the campaign

Jamie Forbes on his way to scoring his team's third try, which completed in impressive fightback from 18 points down. Image: John Williamson
Jamie Forbes on his way to scoring his team's third try, which completed in impressive fightback from 18 points down. Image: John Williamson

Watsonians 24

Heriot’s 21


FROM 18 points behind on the half-hour mark, Watsonians staged a stirring recovery to secure a win which puts them three points clear at the summit of the Super6 table with only one match left to play in the regular season (against Southern Knights on 29th February). Their nearest challengers, Heriot’s and Ayrshire Bulls, play each other in the final round of the campaign so one of them will drop points, which means the Myreside men are now guaranteed a home play-off.

Both head coaches agreed after this one that Lewis Berg‘s converted try just before half-time to make it 10-21 at the break was the key moment in the contest, giving Watsonians the positive nudge they needed for another rousing fight-back, of the sort which has become something of a trademark for Fergus Pringle‘s side this season.

“We felt we weren’t bad in the first half, there was just a few mistakes we made and Heriot’s took their chances really well,” said Pringle. “Scoring that try just before half-time made a massive difference for us. There is a big difference between going in at 21-10 and going in with it 21-3. I think in the second half we actually chased the game a bit too hard, and I think we could have scored a few more tries if we had been a bit more clinical and stuck to what we wanted to do. But having said that, we lost some key players and had to shift personnel round which meant we lost a bit of continuity.”

“I’m just really proud of the boys for the character they showed. They stuck in there and didn’t drop their heads. I think it is in the memory-bank because they have done it before. We’ve got a good group of players here who work hard and get on well, and I’m sure the other teams are the same – but we’ve managed to win some key moments in big games, and it has become a habit.”

Super6: Boroughmuir Bears hunt morale boosting win against Ayrshire Bulls

Tennent’s Premiership preview – runners, riders and verdict for 15th February

Super6: Watsonians and Heriot’s collide in top-of-the-table clash

Heriot’s coach Phil Smith reasoned that his team’s destiny is still in their own hands. If they beat the Bulls in their final game, they get a home play-off. So, he was generally philosophical about the defeat although frustrated by certain aspects of the game.

“We lost a score just before half-time, and then we lost Jason Hill and Adam Sinclair [to injury] who give us a bit of power, so that didn’t help,” he said. “But for a free-kick to be given at a line-out for closing the gap when there is so much movement is really disappointing, and they scored from that. Then I don’t think we got one decision in the second half. There was a scrum at the end there when we ran over the top of them and he gives them the penalty, which is just not good for us.”

“At the same time, our game management was poor. We gave away two or three dumb penalties when we were in a position where we could have got a little bit of momentum and pressure.”

“We defended really well, but you can’t keep defending. You have to get your hands on the ball but we just kept on turning it over. To get a bonus-point was a positive because they will have felt they had chances to score at least one more try given that we went 40 minutes without the ball.”

Edinburgh pro Chris Dean was in the No 12 jersey for Heriot’s to get game time following a pectoral injury sustained last September, and it took him all of two minutes to make his mark, when he collected the ball in midfield and cut inside his man from a standing start, then brushed off at least two more challenges on his way to dotting down under the posts.

Watsonians nibbled into that early lead with an 11th minute offside penalty via stand-off and captain Lee Millar, but Heriot’s were a team on a mission at this point and they cruised further ahead when another incisive intervention from Dean and slick hands under pressure from full-back Ross Jones sent James Couper scampering up the right touchline and over the whitewash.

A penalty try, with Watsonians No 8 Morgan Inness also being sent to the cooler for illegally trying to derail a powerful Heriot’s line-out drive, made it 3-21 just before the half-hour mark – and when Watsonians sent a very kickable penalty to the corner then lost the line-out it looked an even longer way back for the hosts.

But they showed admirable resilience to keep Heriot’s hemmed back inside their own 22 and grasped that all-important lifeline just before the break when Berg scored wide on the left a few minutes later, with Millar nailing the touchline conversion for good measure.

Watsonians scored penalty try of their own at the start of the second half, once again for a collapsed line-out drive, and all of a sudden it was a four point game, and Heriot’s were a man down with open-side Jack McLean being sent to the sin-bin.

Things started to loosen up. It was a bit harum-scarum at times, if the truth be told, and there was some high farce when Watsonians replacement scrum-half Ali Harris fired a pass into the back of team-mate Mesulame Kunavula‘s head – but it was the home side who made it work for them when full-back Jamie Forbes backed himself ahead of an overlap on the right and it paid off for a 65th minute try, which was converted by Millar to establish that all-important three-point advantage.

Watsonians were now well on top, and Heriot’s were flustered, putting themselves under more pressure when a pass infield from a clearance kick didn’t go to hand and Berg hacked on to set up a long spell camped inside the away team’s 22. The hosts were held up over the line on three occasions as they pushed hard for the bonus-point try, but they couldn’t burst the dam.

Heriot’s spent the final few minutes trying desperately to break from their own half to salvage the game, but when Dean went from hero to villain by inexplicably opting to dink over the top after the hooter had sounded, Watsonians mopped up the ball and fired it out of play to secure the win.

Error, group does not exist! Check your syntax! (ID: 27)

Teams –

Watsonians: J Forbes; L Macpherson, L Berg, J Reynolds, A Guthrie; L Millar, M Scott (A Harris 40); H Courtney, C Davies, J Stanley, B Leitch (R Graham 74), J Hodgson, M Badenhorst (H Fisher 48), J Miller, M Inness (M Kunavula 38).

Heriot’s: R Jones; J Couper, C Dean, C Hutchison (S Riddell 79), J Spencer; S Edwards, A Simmers (D Nutton 51); A Nimmo (M Bouab 51), A Johnstone (F Scott 51), J Scott (S Cessford 51), A Sinclair (R Seydak 40), C Jupp, I Wilson, J McLean, J Hill (C Marshall 40).

Referee: Mike Adamson


Scorers –

Watsonians: Try: Berg, Penalty Try, Forbes; Con: Miller 2; Pen: Millar.

Heriot’s: Tries: Dean, Couper, Penalty Try; Cons: Jones 2.

Scoring sequence (Watsonians first): 0-5; 0-7; 3-7; 3-12; 3-14; 3-21; 8-21; 10-21 (h-t) 17-21; 22-21; 24-21


Yellow cards –

Watsonians: Inness

Heriot’s: McLean

Super6: Boroughmuir Bears hunt morale boosting win against Ayrshire Bulls


We hope you’ve enjoyed reading this article

Support our coverage  of all levels of Scottish rugby.

Invest in our gameyou can make a difference by keeping Scottish rugby at all levels in the news.

David Barnes
About David Barnes 1935 Articles
David has worked as a freelance rugby journalist since 2004 covering every level of the game in Scotland for publications including The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The Scotsman/Scotland on Sunday/Evening News, The Herald/Sunday Herald, The Daily Mail/Mail on Sunday and The Sun.


  1. Time to look forward not backwards, regardless of feelings towards SRU/Dodson and taking into account we can not afford a third Pro Team this has to be worth backing for a couple of seasons. It gives the next generation a shop window and a platform to develop. It avoids pro against amateurs, lets judge things in a couple of years. Unless of course there is a better more positive idea (that you wish to make the case for) out there that will improve the standard of Rugby in Scotland and bring on the next generation out with our only two Pro teams.

  2. Most of so called crowd are in with ‘freebie ‘ tickets anyway
    When this stops there will be very few if any punters in ground .
    Interesting when this Super 6 thing started the match reports had crowd numbers over 1000 every game .that stopped very quickly when footage of games appeared
    SRU spin again trying to cover up Dodsons Folly

  3. Opinions sometimes differ. A good top of the league battle but I can’t say my first Super 6 match had me overly excited. The jury is still out for me on this setup. Good comeback from Watsonians in the second half once they had their 15 men back on the pitch again.
    Disappointing crowd if this is a better level of rugby? I will conceed that it was not the warmest of evenings thanks to Dennis!
    Well done to all involved with both teams! A good contested derby match. One match is not enough to give an honest comparrison so I will reserve my full judgement for now.

  4. First game of Super6 tonight and I have to say it was a level above any club rugby I have seen before. Very few mistakes and very physical. Players were huge! This article doesn’t do it justice. Very entertaining game! We will be back!

    • Passing Strange!
      Couldn’t disagree more, Mr Potts! This game was NOT on a level above the former Premiership. You may be right about the physicality – after so much ‘semi-professional’ conditioning that’s only to be expected – but it led to long, boring periods of inconclusive driving and mauling. As for ‘very few mistakes’ we must have watched a different game. Far too much aimless and unnecessary kicking, plus countless basic passing errors that would have shamed 10-year-olds. Passing the ball hard and fast only works when the ball is put in front of recipients’ bellies – not at their feet, or above their heads, or even worse, behind them. Don’t know where you’ve been or what other club games you’ve been watching, but they must have been at an extraordinarily low level for you to call this a ‘very entertaining game’. It was a dreadful advert for so-called ‘Super’ 6 rugby between two top teams who were also contesting a local derby, and the paltry crowd would have been better off watching the Glasgow match on TV.

Comments are closed.