Super6 Sprint: Graham Shiel looks for steady progress from Boroughmuir Bears

Head coach insists that focus at Meggetland will always be on offering opportunities to homegrown players

Graham Shiel. Image: © Craig Watson -
Graham Shiel. Image: © Craig Watson -

GRAHAM SHIEL is refreshingly realistic about what he hopes to achieve with his Boroughmuir Bears squad in the Super6 Sprint series, which starts this coming weekend.

“Our aim is to get better than last season. Clearly we want to win games, and that’s a big driver and a gauge of how successful we are  but it’s not the only measurement of success,” stresses Shiel, who continues to see this tier of rugby as a vehicle for allowing young players to reach higher levels of attainment.

“We want to bring through guys like Duncan Munn to get another year in under-20s, and for others like Rhys Tait to play pro rugby. For us at Boroughmuir, it has been about giving young players opportunities. Hopefully we can continue that. The big thing is how we promote these young guys and put them in the shop window like we did Kaleem Baretto [the Bears’ hugely talented scrum half last season who is now with the Scotland 7s squad].”

TikTok 6N: slow start stymies Scotland as France claim third straight win

Challenge Cup last-16 dates and kick-off times announced

British Army triumph as Melrose Sevens awakens from Covid

Financial constraints and Shiel’s desire to stick to his philosophy of what he sees is the point of Super6 means that it is unlikely that we will see imported marquee players boosting the playing strength at Meggetland, even though Murrayfield has allowed each franchise to have up to four ‘foreigners’ in their roster.

“We’ve not gone down that route [signing non-qualified Scotland players] for a number of reasons,” explained Shield. “It’s too expensive and we would not have been able to sign the quality we wanted. Ideally, we want to bring in players like Jerry Blyth-Lafferty and Liam McConnell, who have come through our club system. They’re both in France right now with the Scotland under-18 side, but when they return we can plug them into Super6 rugby and give them game time. We recognise also that there are players in Edinburgh and the Lothians and Glasgow who want to play Super6.”

Shiel talks enthusiastically about further talent in his squad. “We have players like [second/back row player] Ewan Ferrie, who is an Academy boys, and hooker Corey Tait [from Hawick, who is the younger brother of Rhys], who’ll certainly get a chance this season.”

Another player migrating to Meggetland this season in Josh King, the former Queen Victoria School flanker, who was in Stirling County’s squad last season.

““There’s also more competition now in the centre to challenge Duncan Munn and Robbie McCallum,” suggests Shiel, adding: “Over the piece we’re slightly more competitive in all positions across the squad than we were last season”.

Error, group does not exist! Check your syntax! (ID: 41)


Last season, Boroughmuir Bears brought in a player from England to fill the stand-off position but for the coming series Shiel has avoided going down that route by signing Connor Allan, the son of the dual Scotland and South Africa international hooker, John Allan. The South African youngster, who, of course, is Scotland qualified, will compete for the 10 shirt with ex-St Leonard’s pupil, Harry Mercer,  who is at Durham University. “Hopefully they’ll both settle in and give the outside backs what they need, ,” says Shiel. “I know Harry from old when he was involved in the under-16 programme.”

Boroughmuir Bears had a hit-out against Southern Knights last Friday in a match billed as part of the four-day Melrose Sevens programme. Neither of the two new fly-halves were available for this game, so Shiel opted to give game time to youngster Callum Anderson, who has been playing for the Boroughmuir Club XV in the National One. “I thought Callum played very confidently at this level,” was Shiel’s judgment. Also given a chance at ten last Friday was Adam Scott, the ex GHA player, who according to Shiel is more likely to be used in the back three.

It’s’ not all about youngsters, however. Shiel does not subscribe to the widely held view that Super6 should be for under-25s. “I don’t think I’d have an upper age limit,” he says. “For example you’ve got a guy like Craig Keddie who absolutely loves playing at this level and relishes the chance to play this kind of rugby. To deny him that opportunity would be wrong.

“Also you’ve got guys like Tom Brown who’s transitioning from a bubble [pro rugby] into normal life. This has been a real release for Tom compared to what he had been doing. What they give is experience, leadership and guidance. Tom playing outside Duncan Munn has to be a good thing. Ditto Craig playing alongside Rhys Tait and Ewan Ferrie, giving them experience he’s gained over many years.”

Looking forward Shiel states: “It’s going to be a tough season for us and obviously a tough start against Ayrshire Bulls at Millbrae, but that’s what this Super6 programme is about. It’s about challenging players.”

British Army triumph as Melrose Sevens awakens from Covid

About Alan Lorimer 355 Articles
Scotland rugby correspondent for The Times for six years and subsequently contributed to Sunday Times, Daily and Sunday Telegraph, Scotsman, Herald, Scotland on Sunday, Sunday Herald and Reuters. Worked in Radio for BBC. Alan is Scottish rugby journalism's leading voice when it comes to youth and schools rugby.


  1. No idea how strong the respective squads were, but for what it’s worth the Bears were impressive at Melrose, won the physical battle in the 2nd half.

  2. No squad list in the interview, but by my reckoning the Boroughmuir squad of 32 must be
    Tom Brown, Glenn Faulds, Adam Scott, Callum Ramm, Joe Jenkins, Scott Robeson, Robbie McCallum, Duncan Munn, Ronan Kerr, Connor Allan, Harry Mercer, Murray Johnstone, Rauridh Swan; Ross Dunbar, Tom Banatvala, Brandon Sweet, Corey Tait, Jerry Blyth Lafferty, Dan Winning, Martin McGinley, Marcus Goodwin, Jack Fisher, Ewan Stewart, Euan Ferrie, Josh King, Craig Keddie, Tom Drennan, Aubrey MnCube, Liam McConnell, Trystan Andrews, Scott McGinley Rhys Tait.

    That is 32 players who I have gathered from various sources.

    In addition Glasgow Hawks have announced Iain Carmichael is joining them as injury cover, so not sure who he is covering for.

    There are meant to be 5 Academy players attached to each team, and that list includes McCallum, Ferrie and Tait. But I have not included Mickey Gray or Gregor Brown who were with Boroughmuir last year – the squad may be bigger than 32, and include them, or it is possible (with Murphy Walker and Matthew Currie now on full contracts) that there are additions to the Academy and Duncan Munn and Corey Tait are Academy players now?

    The piecemeal announcements by the clubs of playing rosters have made me wonder if there are still some negotiations going on between clubs as to which clubs get which players? All will be revealed this week. Look forward to a series of TOL articles.

    • Hopefully the other squads follow suit and have as many young Scottish talents as Boroughmuir. To me it looks like half the squad are 22 and under, and the vast majority have come through Scottish clubs/schools.

      • Why would the super six simply be for under 25? There’s a whole lot of late bloomers or athletic beasts who get into rugby at a later time, it would be a shame not to develop such talents too.


Comments are closed.