Super6: Southern Knights revival continues with victory over Ayrshire Bulls

Borderers make win a tense encounter at Millbrae and are now within touching distance of play-off qualification

Neil Irvine-Hess scored Southern Knights' second try before picking up a shoulder injury. Image: Fotosport/David Gibson
Neil Irvine-Hess scored Southern Knights' second try before picking up a shoulder injury. Image: Fotosport/David Gibson

Ayrshire Bulls 20

Southern Knights 29


IF chess was a contact sport, this is what it would look like. A strategic battle, a test of concentration and a challenge of nerve, where any mistake could have catastrophic consequences. It was compelling in its own way, even if there was little in the way of free-flowing rugby on display. In fairness, the boggy pitch made it very hard for the players to generate the momentum they needed to play fast rugby.

The lead changed hands five times before Southern Knights finally manoeuvred themselves into their winning position with ten minutes to go when they scored two tries in fairly quick succession, which also secured the bonus and deprived their opponents of a consolation point.

That’s three wins on the bounce now for the Borderers and the contrast in mood to just before Christmas when they had lost four and managed only one draw from their opening five games is striking. From down and out they are now firmly established in the fourth play-off slot, seven points ahead of Stirling County with two games to play. They are eight points adrift of a home play-off, but in this sort of form they will fancy their chances at Goldenacre, Myreside or, indeed, Millbrae again.

Opinion: Gregor Townsend should look across the Irish Sea for lessons in man-management

Greig Laidlaw set for Perpignan move

Super6: Stirling County deny Watsonians at the death

“Energy and enthusiasm can take you a long way, especially in conditions like that,” reflected victorious head coach Rob Chrystie afterwards. “I think you can see within the group they are beginning to come together and get stronger through knowing each other a bit better.

“I believe we can be better than that performance, so that’s the focus,” he added. “There was definitely opportunities out there that we didn’t take, they were able to put us under pressure at times so we’ve got to look at that, and I think they scored their first try a bit easily so we just need to be a little bit more resilient in that instance.”

“Having said that, there was a period just after half-time when they threw pretty much everybody at a maul on our line and we held them out. They got a penalty but they weren’t going to score, so there’s moments like that which we need to build on. There was some really good stuff in there, too.”

Southern Knights took the lead on 14 minutes through a penalty try, with home No 8 Blair Macpherson also being sent to the sin-bin for collapsing the line-out drive as it motored with uncompromising purpose towards the Bulls’ line.

That jolted the hosts into a near immediate response, and there was a sense of déjà vu when they sent a penalty to the corner then muscled their way towards the scoring zone – with the difference this time being that it ended with hooker Sam Kitchen grounding the ball for his sixth try of the season, rather than a penalty try award.

Ross Thomson nailed the touchline conversion, then edged Bulls into the lead with a penalty from in front of the posts, which was awarded for an offside after Craig Gossman had weaved his way through three defenders to establish the field position. Ten unanswered points during their period with a man less must have been pretty satisfying for the home camp.

There was a flashpoint just before the half hour mark when Bulls scrum-half David Armstrong hurtled into a tackle on Patrick Anderson and appeared to catch the Knights winger around the neck/chin area, which had the away support and coaching team howling for a red card – but referee Sam Grove-White decided, after consultation with his touch-judge, that a yellow was sufficient sanction.

After an exchange of penalties between Struan Hutchison for the Knights and Thomson for the Bulls, the visitors snatched a half-time lead when Fraser Thomson’s clearance kick was allowed to bounce, Grant Shiells hacked ahead, and Neil Irvine-Hess won the race to the ball as it skidded over the try-line.

There was a lengthy hold-up at the start of the second half while Irvine-Hess was treated on the park and then stretchered off with shoulder injury. Chrystie indicated afterwards that the medical response was largely precautionary and he was hopeful that the player’s trip to hospital would confirm that the injury is not too serious.

When the action resumed, the Bulls laid siege to the opposition line, and after being held-up once they eventually got their reward when Kitchen muscled over yet again, for his try number seven of the campaign.

That was the cue for the pendulum to swing once again, and Southern Knights were soon back in front when Fraser Renwick rescued a scrappy line-out, Dylan Taylor – whose striking hairstyle makes him look like the horse in Shrek – pierced the defensive line, and Conor Young capitalised by picking up straight from the tackle and taking route one over the whitewash.

Then came the decisive score. Replacement scrum-half Bruce Colvine sensed open ground behind a ruck on the right of the park and sent a well weighted dink over the top, Thomson hacked ahead and Ciaran Whyte added the finishing touch.

“The pitch was extremely heavy so it made putting tempo into you attack very difficult, so it was going to be very difficult to chase a lead,” lamented beaten head coach Peter Murchie. “We got ourselves into a winning position at 20-17 and let is slip from there.

“We made way too many mistakes today. There was a lot of kicking and we made two bad errors in the backfield which led to tries for them, so we gave them too many points.”

The Bulls are still in line for a home play-off if they win their last two games of the regular season against Boroughmuir Bears at Meggetland on 15th February and Heriot’s at Goldenacre on 1st March.

“We’ve lost our mojo a little bit and there is no magic wand that will get our form back for us, its about hard work and we just have to drive higher standards than we showed today,” concluded Murchie. “First things first, we have to win at Boroughmuir, and we’ll think about what comes next after that.”

Teams –

Ayrshire Bulls: G Anderson; M Davidson T Beary (I McNulty 65), T Jordan, C Gossman (H Warr 70); R Thompson, D Armstrong; M Scott (R Sayce 74), S Kitchen (L Anderson 65), N Griffiths, M Sykes (G Geldenhuys 70), L Morrice, G Bordill  (G Geldenhuys 70), P McCallum©, B Macpherson.

Southern Knights: F Thomson; C Whyte, J Jenkins, G Wood (B Colvine 49), P Anderson; T Galbraith, S Hutchison; G Shiells (C Young 55), F Renwick (F Scott 76), E Mcquillan (S Gunn 55), J Head, A Runciman, R Knott, D Taylor, N Irvine-Hess (I Moody 45).

Referee: Sam Grove-White


Scorers –

Ayrshire Bulls: Tries: Kitchen 2; Con: Thomson 2; Pen: Thomson 2.

Southern Knights: Tries: Penalty Try, Irvine-Hess, Young, Whyte; Con: Hutchison 2; Pen: Hutchison

Scoring sequence (Ayrshire Bulls): 0-7; 5-7; 7-7; 10-7; 10-10; 13-10; 13-15; 13-17 (h-t) 18-17; 20-17; 20-22; 20-27; 20-29.


Yellow cards –

Ayrshire Bulls: Macpherson, Armstrong

Man-of-the-Match: The line-out was a bit of a lottery at times but Southern Knights hooker Fraser Renwick got the nod after an industrious performance at the pit-face.

Talking point: After five games without a win at the start of the season, the Southern Knights are now motoring – would you bet against them?

Super6: Heriot’s humble Boroughmuir Bears in nine-try rout

About David Barnes 3908 Articles
David has worked as a freelance rugby journalist since 2004 covering every level of the game in Scotland for publications including he Herald/Sunday Herald, The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The Scotsman/Scotland on Sunday/Evening News, The Daily Record, The Daily Mail/Mail on Sunday and The Sun.


  1. Bryce makes a good point. I watched this online for a bit – the ground conditions were poor and adversely impacted the quality on offer.

    Summer rugby anyone?

    • If you can predict summer weather in scotland then I want your lottery numbers as well.

      This is a simple sounding solution to a much more complex problem.

      To be serious though. I’ve seen flooding in the summer and games would have been off if they had been scheduled.

      Growing season is spring & summer so you are proposing we play in pitches when they are recovering from winter? And then when we stop playing we won’t be able to do pitch maintenance because the grass won’t grow.

      And the issue of rock hard baked pitches – in those odd days we get some sunshine – won’t be just a different problem?

      Not to mention clubs who also have cricket played at their grounds.

      Might be more a question of what will it take to improve our playing pitches. Better drainage?

  2. If this goes belly up due to lack of interest from punters I wonder what Buffoon at Murrayfield will have to admit he made a Horlicks of Scottish rugby

  3. I know the ground conditions were heavy but something has to be done to reduce the aerial ping-pong. Strategically it can work, but rugby won’t survive without paying punters.
    Yes, I am an Ayr supporter, but I am first & foremost a paying punter.

Comments are closed.