Super Series Championship: Southern Knights edge a long-awaited win over Future XV

Lively contest provides both sides cause for encouragement – but much stiffer challenges lie ahead

Image courtesy: Scottish Rugby Twitter feed.
Image courtesy: Scottish Rugby Twitter feed.

Southern Knights 39

Future XV 38

ALAN LORIMER @ The Greenyards

IF the pre-match forecast was leaning towards a young Futures XV being unable to cope with the power of a seasoned Super Series side then the newcomers turned that notion on its head, and but for a last minute miss at goal they would have come away with a not undeserved win. 

In the event, the single point victory by Southern Knights may prove to be a fillip for the beleaguered Greenyards consortium after a torrid time in the recent Sprint series. And a boost too for Alan Tait, who admitted: “It was my first win as head coach of the Knights, but we know that there’s a lot of work to do. We’ve had a lot of disruption in the last two weeks with players on holiday and injuries.”

Despite the win, Tait revealed that his players were disappointed with the game. “They had done the work in the first half and everybody thought they would click into gear and pile on the points,” he added. “But fair play to the Futures. They had a hard job getting a team together but were helped by some good players from the Wolves. They scored some belters of tries. They had a chance to win the game with a kick at the end but that’s the way it goes. We’ve all won and lost games like that”.

Super Series round one Saturday preview: Ayrshire Bulls host Watsonians

Junior World Trophy: Scotland Under-20s steel themselves for final outing versus Samoa

Scotland v Italy: 10 talking points from Gregor Townsend’s team announcement

The pain of losing by one point should not in any way reduce the credit the young Futures XV richly deserves. Throughout the youngsters were unfazed by their opponentS and showed impressive skill in executing many of their moves.

Future XV coach Scott Lawson suggested that what was once referred to as the hypotenuse of youth was apparent throughout their performance. “The energy on both sides of the ball in attack and defence from us was outstanding,” he said. “The amount of opportunities they took and the amount they created and capitalised on was impressive. It came down to key moments in the game but this group is motivated by learning and developing.

“As to the game itself ,I thought we were the more dominant team throughout the match but there were just one or two key moments when Knights’ experience and seniority counted. But the boys will learn from this.”


The energy that Lawson spoke of was evident in the youngsters’ opening play, the Futures wasting little time in making an impression with a spectacular try from a finely angled run by winger Amena Caqusau, with Isaac Coates adding the conversion for a 7-0 lead.

The score, however, had the effect of shaking Knights into action and when they drove a five-metre line-out the outcome was predictable, hooker Luke Thompson claiming the points. Then from a plentiful supply of ball Knights added two scores in quick succession both from long cut-out passes by stand-off Callum Grieve that yielded unconverted tries in opposite corners for winger Aidan Cross and full-back Donald Crawford.

But any thought that Knights would dominate proceedings thereafter were soon shattered with a period of pressure from the Future XV that tested the home side’s defence and which ultimately produced a try from prop Callum Smyth, to go into the break 22-12 down.

The gap narrowed immediately after the interval after Future XV attacked from the kick-off and from a sweeping move that benefitted from the support play of Oliver Duncan, fellow back-row Freddy Douglas was on hand to nail the score, Coates adding his second conversion.

Knights quickly replied with a second try by Crawford and the conversion by Grieve only to concede a score to the Future XV when Jake Spurway crashed over from close range, becoming a seven pointer following Coates’ third conversion success.

Then, when replacement Chris Bell was carded, Future XV made hay from their man advantage, scoring from a five metre line-out through benchman Tom Smith and the conversion by Coates.

Matters became worse for Knights when Duncan forced his way over from close range for an unconverted try,  countered within minutes by a score in the corner from Garry Young via a pinpoint pass from replacement stand-off Harris Rutherford. Grieve’s conversion then narrowed the Future XV lead to two points.

With just three minutes of play remaining, Knights regained the lead with a Grieve penalty. It seemed that was that until on full-time Knights gave away a penalty in front of the posts. All it needed was for Coates to knock over the kick. Sadly for the talented stand-off the ball was hooked slightly wide of the posts leaving Knights winners by the narrowest of margins


Teams –

Southern Knights: D Crawford; A Cross, H Bentle, A Hall, R Cottrell; G McNeish, R Brand©; J Dobie, L Thompson, D Gamble, A Runciman, A Ferrie, H Borthwick, W Ferrie, G Young. Substitutes: F Barry, C Greer, A Dodds, T Brown, M Wilson, C Bell, H Rutherford, C Grieve.

Future XV: S Wilson; A Caqusau, M Herron, C Ferrie, S Rockley; I Coates, E Davey; C Smyth, M Brogan, M Ogunlaja, J Spurway, J Pow, S MacDonald, F Douglas, O Duncan. Substitutes: M Cantle, A Cameron, L Skinner, T Smith, C Nolan, R Cadzow, C Scott, B Riley.

Referee: Jonny Perriman


Scorers –

Southern Knights: Tries Thompson 2, Cross, Crawford 2, Young; Cons: Grieve 3;  Pen: Grieve.

Future XV: Tries: Caqusau, Smyth, Douglas, Spurway, Smith, Duncan: Cons: Coates 4.

Scoring Sequence (Southern Knights first): 0-5; 0-7; 5-7; 10-7; 15-7; 22-7; 22-12 (h-t) 22-17; 22-19; 27-19; 29-19; 29-24; 29-26; 29-31; 29-33; 29-38; 34-38; 36-38.


Yellow cards –

Southern Knights: Bell


Man-of-the-Match: In such a close game there were a number of candidates (on both sides) for the MOTM but for sheer energy, clever support running and strong defence Futures’ No 8 Ollie Duncan wins the accolade, just fractionally ahead of his back-row colleague Freddy Douglas and centre Callum Ferrie, and Knights’ hooker Luke Thompson.

Talking point: Both sides were missing a shoal of players which made the game a tad artificial. Knights’ first win for some time, however, will be a considerable confidence lifter for the Greenyards men but perhaps it was the Future XVs that may have gained most from this encounter.  They will still be without their Kenya contingent for several weeks but even with the current squad they can look forward to being competitive against what will admittedly be much stiffer opposition. Finally, a word for stand-off Isaac Coates who must have felt the utter disappointment of missing a match winning goal on full-time. But Coates looked very competent as a 10 throughout, begging the question of why he was not in Nairobi with the Scotland Under-20 squad?

Super Series round one Saturday preview: Ayrshire Bulls host Watsonians

About Alan Lorimer 339 Articles
Scotland rugby correspondent for The Times for six years and subsequently contributed to Sunday Times, Daily and Sunday Telegraph, Scotsman, Herald, Scotland on Sunday, Sunday Herald and Reuters. Worked in Radio for BBC. Alan is Scottish rugby journalism's leading voice when it comes to youth and schools rugby.


  1. Can anyone more enlightened that I answer a burning question I have. Once the super series is finished, what do players do for the rest of the season? do they go back to their old clubs?

    • They’ll all be contracted to Edinburgh & Glasgow at end of season will they not ?

      That’s what this is for according to the ‘High Heed Yin ‘ He who must be obeyed ‘

      Then There will be a new intake next year from the abundance of young rugby players coming through .

      Then I woke up .it’s all a dream …some of them won’t have a team to back to shortly as
      Dodson’s killing rugby in Scotland

  2. Mr Jedlad That’s why borders rugby is on the way out
    Self interest and tribalism at its best from mr Jed look at the 7s and the clubs not supporting each other

    I was at the game and I have seen worse crowds , it was a great game well done to all the players

    Sadly your comments are why the rest of the country laugh at the borders

    • And your sweeping generalisations and pomposity in claiming to speak for the rest of the country is why I am laughing at you.

      (Note I don’t claim to speak for others).

  3. It must be very difficult to plan for a competition which constantly changes and you can’t blame players who have booked holidays long in advance of any match dates being announced for deciding to spend time with their families rather than playing in this Mickey Mouse competition.

    But nothing will change as long as Dodson and his mates are being paid their excessive salary and bonuses. They have little interest in the future of Scottish rugby beyond their bank balances.

  4. Well done the Future XV, what a brilliant effort, which sets you up well for this coming campaign. Your all in the spotlight, therefore make the most of this season’s opportunities 👍🙂🏉

  5. The 10 may not be in Nairobi as he’s only in the under 18’s Scotland team as he is only 17 ! A good crowd saw an excellent game of rugby tonight

  6. Let’s not overhype the “win” , Futures were the better team tonight which should be a concern to coaches that have had the benefit of the Suoer 6 sprint as a run in to the Series albeit you would not think it from what was on offer tonight. Another sparse crowd again confirming the Borders apathy with the Knights ….

      • Just watched the highlights….unless the stands were full of people dressed as empty seats it was almost empty….20-30 folk at best. The crowds at all 2 games were a joke compared to club rugby. Ayr attract a crowd commensurate with the likes of Highland and Bigger What a colossal waste of money.

  7. Another example of the shambolic organisation. Why , when players are signed for Super series and have been in pre season training for months do some of the franchises already appear short of players for the first game ? There is a bit of an excuse for the Futures given half their team is in Kenya but no excuse for other teams. Surely for the first game of the season it would be reasonable for supporters to expect a full roster available for this process. It does not bode well for the remainder of the Super 7 particularly seeing how teams struggled at the end of the Sprint in similar fashion due to injuries. The fact there are now 7 teams just means that personnel is spread even thinner and I fully expect a lot if disruption to the League teams that will undoubtedly have to fill the void for this poorly organised and thought through competition.
    I would like to understand why the Knights were short tonight and why they had to “borrow” players from Melrose already ??
    The Knights won the game tonight by the skin of their teeth but questions have to be asked about how a team that has done a full pre season was made to look second best by a team thrown together in less than a week ?
    I just don’t see how this will work , there is not the volume of players to support the Super 7 when taken in the context of a Scottish League season running alongside it and I predict a complete shambles.. again.


Comments are closed.