UPDATED: Scotland v France: Thomson starts as Townsend makes 14 changes

Stuart Hogg only player to keep his place in starting line-up

Blade Thomson at a Scotland training session. Image: © Craig Watson. www.craigwatson.co.uk

BLADE Thomson will make his long-awaited Scotland debut against France on Saturday in a starting line-up that shows 14 changes from the one that began  last week’s 32-3 defeat by the same opponents. The Scarlets forward will start at No 8, while hooker Grant Stewart will also win his first cap if he comes off the bench.

Full-back Stuart Hogg is the only player to retain his place from the match in Nice, and remains one of the two vice-captains in the team, along with Ryan Wilson, who is at blindside. Greig Laidlaw takes over the captaincy from Stuart McInally, and is partnered at half-back by Finn Russell.

“I think it was actually going to be 15 changes at one stage but seeing as Stuart Hogg left the field early with cramp [last Saturday], we decided that he could do with another game,” explained Townsend. “He was looking pretty sharp before he came off and he was very keen to play.”

Six week ban rules French second-row Paul Gabrillagues out of World Cup

France v Scotland: Matt Taylor vows to tackle attitude problem

Edinburgh sign Scotland Under-20s hooker Ewan Ashman on loan

Lock Scott Cummings starts his first Test after making his debut off the bench last week, and plays alongside Sam Skinner. Rory Hutchinson is among the replacements and could also make his second Scotland appearance.

Thomson was originally called into the squad for last year’s Autumn Internationals, but injury prevented him from making his appearance then. He takes his place in a pack which looks considerably beefier than the one which conceded second best by a long way in the first World Cup warm-up game in France.

“We did look at starting Blade last week but given where he was in terms of training at that time, we thought it would be better if he had another week,” explained Townsend. “He has trained really well and we feel he is ready to play now,”

“The plan over the first two weeks was to play the majority of the squad and put two teams out that we believed were strong enough to Test matches. Obviously, that wasn’t the case last week, and now it is up to this group of players to rectify that on Saturday.

“We’ve reflected a lot on the build-up to last weekend’s game – the week’s training, the day itself, what we could have done differently as coaches. We focussed a lot on ourselves going into the build-up. In normal Test matches we’d probably look at the opposition 20-30 percent and ourselves 70-80 percent, but, in this case, it was a lot about our game and we obviously weren’t able to impose our game in attack or defence.

“So, it has narrowed our minds. It was a painful lesson for players and coaches that we have to do much better in the build-up, and we have to deliver a much better performance in the game.

“We’ve seen how the players have reacted in training and how they’ve reacted in their meetings – their focus and edge compared to last week has certainly been present in training.

“It is obviously a different group of players, but they feel as hurt as the team that went out at the weekend did.

“So, we will see a better performance, and it has to be a lot better because France are in great shape and they’ve picked a stronger team this weekend.”

Scotland (v France at Murrayfield, Saturday, 1.10pm): S Hogg; T Seymour, C Harris, P Horne, S Maitland; F Russell, G Laidlaw; G Reid, G Turner, W Nel, S Cummings, S Skinner, R Wilson, H Watson, B Thomson. Substitutes: G Stewart, A Dell, S Berghan, G Gilchrist, J Barclay, G Horne, R Hutchinson, B Kinghorn.

France v Scotland: Matt Taylor vows to tackle attitude problem


We hope you’ve enjoyed reading this article

Support our new, improved coverage this season 2019-20, with Super 6, National 1 and 2 leagues, fixtures and tables, and the small matter of our comprehensive coverage of Scotland at the RWC from Japan.

Invest in our gameyou can make a difference by keeping Scottish rugby at all levels in the news.

The Grudge by Tom English
Stuart Bathgate
About Stuart Bathgate 799 Articles
Stuart has been the rugby correspondent for both The Scotsman and The Herald, and was also The Scotsman’s chief sports writer for 14 years from 2000.


  1. Delighted to see so many wholesale changes, I don’t think last week’s abject performance can be normalized. Obviously aswell as trying out a few different players, a clear message has been relayed that we cannot perform at that level to have any hope of achieving anything. Exciting side overall, strong back-row that could work nicely in tandem. Centre partnership a little under-whelming though to be honest, Jones needs a confidence boost and was not the worst offender last weekend- I would have played him again this time round. Really excited to see what Stewart can do, aswell as Horne Jnr and Hutchison off the bench.

  2. Interesting selection for a big game if we are to get some confidence for the WC.
    Looking forward to seeing how Blade Thomson goes, his NZ footage is impressive and he will suit the “fastest rugby” style Gregor is trying to play.
    Part of what is however a relatively light back five of the pack, who will need to front up big time after last week’s shellacking.
    Also interested in how two of Gregor’s favourites Horne and Harris go in the centre. Neither do much for me at this level. Suspect they will either prove Gregor right or play themselves off the plane.
    Still can’t help feeling Richie Gray should be on that plane. Cotter picked the Gray brothers often and it seemed to bring out the best in both, with each having more ballast than any other of our second rows.

Comments are closed.