Scotland v Australia: hosts pick up third consecutive win against Wallabies

Hamish Watson and debutant Ewan Ashman score the tries for home side

Scotland captain Stuart Hogg joins the celebrations for Hamish Watson's try. Image: © Craig Watson -
Scotland captain Stuart Hogg joins the celebrations for Hamish Watson's try. Image: © Craig Watson -

Scotland 15

Australia 13

DAVID BARNES @ Murrayfield

A GAME of cat and mouse ended with Scotland purring in satisfaction and Australia squeaking in frustration. Two teams who pride themselves on playing lively, attacking rugby, couldn’t quite impose themselves like we know they can with ball in hand, but that won’t matter a jot to the victorious hosts, who showed plenty of courage and nerve to pick up their third win on the bounce against these opponents.

The Wallabies arrived at Murrayfield riding high on a five-match winning streak, although they were without three of their big performers from those recent successes who have opted to stay with their Japanese clubs rather than tour with their country. Scotland can only beat what is put in front of them, and over the course of the 80 minutes they deserved this result – even if the Wallabies will be frustrated at having two first-half tries chalked off for offences during the build-up.

Next up for Scotland is South Africa at Murrayfield. A huge challenge against the Lions-conquering world champions, but Australia beat the Springboks in back-to-back matches at the start of September, and Wales gave them a run for their money yesterday, so Gregor Townsend‘s boys will feel they have nothing to fear.

Obituary: Sandy Carmichael: “… one of the bravest and fairest players to grace the game”

London Scottish hope to be part of ‘Super8’ for 2022-23 season

Ayr Rugby Club unveil big plans for £3 million legacy windfall

Australian playmaker James O’Connor passed up an opportunity to nudge the visitors into a fourth minute lead when he pushed his shot at goal to the right of the posts after Sam Skinner was penalised for a side entry.

Darcy Graham was clearly eager to make his mark during this opening period, sprinting 30-yards at one point to take a quick tap penalty, although he was fortunate a few minutes later when his attempt at triggering something from deep led to an interception only for Australian outside-centre Len Ikitau to lose his footing with the try-line at his mercy.

There was plenty of intent during this period, but not quite the accuracy required for either side to really hit their straps.

There was a moment to get the crowd going when Stuart Hogg somehow found his way through a crowd of gold jerseys to launch an attack up the left touchline, carried on by Ali Price and then Duhan van der Merwe. When the big winger was eventually brought down, Australia went off their feet, but Scotland failed to capitalise on that penalty in the danger zone.

A few minutes later, there was confusion when Hogg was caught in possession and jostled back over his own line. It looked like he had managed to offload off the deck for Graham to clear, but referee Romain Poite wasn’t so sure, initially giving a scrum-five to Australia, then a line-out to the tourists when the big screen indicated the ball had not been grounded, then a scrum again when the TMO insisted it had been grounded. It was a fuss over nothing in the end, with Australia being penalised for going off their feet in the next play,  and the game returning to the middle of the park battle it had been for the first 15 minutes.

Finally, the deadlock was broken when Scotland passed up three easy points to kick an offside penalty to the corner, and were rewarded with a Hamish Watson try off a clever move initiated by middle-jumper Jamie Ritchie tapping down to Grant Gilchrist at the front. There was another hold-up as Poite and the TMO discussed a possible obstruction, but the referee ultimately went with his on-field decision.

Australia were left frustrated when Tom Wright went over on the left, only for play to be pulled back for an off-the-ball tackle earlier in the passage of play, but the Wallabies kept the pressure on and they had another try chalked off on 35 minutes when tight-head Allan Alaalatoa was judged, perhaps harshly, to have caught Matt Fagerson with a swinging arm as he cleared out a ruck just before Michael Hooper stretched over the line.

To add to the away team’s sense of grievance, they were also reduced to 14 men for the next 10 minutes with Alaalatoa being sent to the sin-bin, but they didn’t let that distract them, and O’Connor finally got Australia off the mark on 39 minutes with a well-struck penalty after Matt Fagerson was penalised for going off his feet.


Season Appeal 2022 - 2023

We hope you are enjoying our unrivalled coverage of Scottish Rugby. While mainstream media continues to reduce its interest in the rugby family in Scotland, The Offside Line does its very best to make sure all levels of the domestic game are reported.

Our commitment to the game and sharing its stories means that we do not have a paywall, so we would ask you (only if you can!) to support The Offside Line, either with a one off donation, or with a monthly contribution.

We have been keeping Scottish rugby in the news since 2016 and will have 3 million page views this year, making The Offside Line first for Scottish rugby.



A massive collision when Sam Johnson carried into Taniela Tupou left the Australian replacement tight-head clearly concussed and he had to be replaced, meaning Australia had two loose-heads at the next scrum, but it stacked up and after a powerful burst through the middle by Izaia Perese, the ball was sent back the way it had come and Rob Leota charged through a gaping hole between Pierre Schoeman and Sam Skinner to score, with O’Connor adding the conversion.

Scotland looked to bounce back immediately, with Johnson looping round to create an opening on the left, and Price once again on hand to keep the move going, but the move floundered when Matt Fagerson lost possession in contact.

There was a fair bit cautious kicking for territory during this third quarter. Then, after an excellent 50-22 by Finn Russell set up a great line-out platform, and slick hands gave van der Merwe the chance of a gallop on the left, before Nic White did well to bring the big man down. Play swept back to the right, but Hogg’s pass to Graham was cut-out by Tom Wright.

Eventually, the pressure told, with hooker Ewan Ashman marking his international debut by carrying on the prolific try-scoring record of his Scotland Under-20s days with a brilliantly taken try under pressure in the left corner.

Australia got their noses back in front when O’Connor nailed the points from 40-yards out and directly in front of the posts after Watson was penalised as he tried to pilfer possession over a tackle, but Russell responded in kind with just over 20 minutes to go after a collapsed scrum, and that’s how it stayed until the end.

Scotland closed out the game well. There was some good work from Jamie Hodgson and Ritchie when they tag-teamed Kurtley Beale to prevent the recycle and win a vital scrum, while replacements Kyle Steyn and Josh Bayliss – on debut – both won excellent turnovers.

The Bayliss turnover prompted a sweeping attack involving Russell, Hogg, Steyn and George Horne, before a tackle was taken when a pass inside looked the better option, and when the ball was recycled Russell over-cooked a cross-field kick and it went out on the full. It was a shame the Scots couldn’t finish with a flourish, but nobody of a tartan hue will be losing much sleep over that.


Teams –

Scotland: S Hogg; D Graham (K Steyn 60), C Harris, S Johnson (A Hastings 73), D van der Merwe; F Russell, A Price (G Horne 72); P Schoeman (J Bhatti 66), G Turner (E Ashman 11), Z Fagerson (O Kebble 66), S Skinner ( J Hodgson 63), G Gilchrist, J Ritchie, H Watson (J Bayliss 72), M Fagerson.

Australia: A Kellaway; J Petaia (I Perese 39), L Ikitau, H Paisami, T Wright (K Beale 67); J O’Connor, N White (T McDermott 67); J Slipper, F Fainga’a (C McInerney 73), A Alaalatoa (A Bell 55-63), R Arnold (W Skelton 50), I Rodda, R Leota (P Samu 60), M Hooper, R Valetini (T Tupou 38, A Bell 43, R Valetini 45).


Scorers –

Scotland: Tries: Watson, Ashman; Con: Russell; Pen: Russell.

Australia: Try: Leota; Con: O’Connor; Pen: O’Connor 2.

Scoring Sequence (Scotland first): 5-0; 7-0; 7-3 (h-t) 7-8; 7-10; 12-10; 12-13; 15-13;


Yellow cards –

Australia: Alaalatoa (36mins)


Attendance: 67,144.

Premiership: injury-time score snatches draw for Jed-Forest at Selkirk

Premiership: GHA return to action with morale-boosting win over Musselburgh

Premiership: Currie Chieftains stay top after winning epic battle versus Hawick

Premiership: Edinburgh Accies school Aberdeen Grammar in art of grinding out a win

Premiership: Glasgow Hawks ground down as Marr march on

About David Barnes 3264 Articles
David has worked as a freelance rugby journalist since 2004 covering every level of the game in Scotland for publications including he Herald/Sunday Herald, The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The Scotsman/Scotland on Sunday/Evening News, The Daily Record, The Daily Mail/Mail on Sunday and The Sun.


  1. “when tight-head Allan Alaalatoa was judged, perhaps harshly, to have caught Matt Fagerson with a swinging arm”

    Absolutely nothing harsh about that decision. Fagerson is on the other side of the ruck, not contesting the ball, and not needing to be cleared out.

    Yet the Prop tucked his arm and went for him. Only his awful aim prevented him receiving a red, rather than a yellow card.

    If Fagerson threw a punch at an Aussie, but it missed, would be have been let off without sanction?

  2. A win’s a win, but that won’t be a game to live long in the memory. That being said, the collision between Johnson and the supposedly fearsome Tongan Thor might get a replay occasionally.
    I wasn’t confident ahead of this game, simply because we hadn’t played together for a while and the Aussies have. Yes, they were lacking one or two first choices, but the bulk of the team who’ve strung together 5 wins were available.
    Our scrum was effective and the lineouts well worked, with Watson’s try very smart. Some of the decision making in the backs was weak and I got the impression Graham was trying too hard to make an impact. He’s there on merit and doesn’t have to prove himself. Horne is perhaps lucky his rivals lack experience, as his current form does leave something to desire.
    Ashman did very well and Bayliss looked lively, so it’s good to see the squad growing with quality additions. Next weekend will be an interesting battle.

    PS Was that worthy of a yellow card?

    • I’d say it was worthy of a card. He was clearing out someone who was already out of play and not a threat to the ball whatsoever, it could/was construed as malicious, certainly unnecessary.

    • ‘Yes, they were lacking one or two first choices’ do you not think that arguably there were one or two missing through injury in our Squad? Just a thought.

  3. Very satisfying to get a victory over an in-form top-level team despite not playing all that well. That’s what the best teams are capable of doing, and yesterday felt like another step in the right direction.

  4. It’s easy on how to approach the game, ATTACK, ATTACK AND ATTACK again lol. I say that because it’s how the game should be played, none of this kick tennis borefest! Hopefully we are defensively on it though as it will be tougher to stop them than it was v Australia.

  5. That felt like a game we would have let slip not so long ago. Ashman looks a natural, Gilchrist worked tirelessly, Matt Fagerson starting to look like the finished product.

    Poite reffed well in his final test. Looking forward to SA – that’ll be another step up again.

  6. Tight win but that will do. A couple of cases of white line fever Johnson should have given it to VDM and Horne to anyone. That said Ashman did do well though sorry for Turner, and Schoeman did well and Graham was lively. The scrum was impressive, as well. I’ll have to watch some highlights but a great display and it’s great to see a full ground again.

    • The Horne break, I thought in real time he should’ve passed it, but when you watch it back, the two guys on his left have australian players right behind them, so would’ve been tackled almost straight away and there would be no support. Horne taking contact meant that there were players to secure the ruck.

      Whether that’s what was going through Horne’s head is a different matter, but it was ultimately the correct decision.

  7. Funny old game started by throwing it wide without earning it. Russell doing more wrong than right and very little structure. Defended superbly and given that Australia had just beaten SA twice and NZ a win is a wonderful result.
    No sure if Johnson/Harris works at centre.
    Onto next week with confidence…..

  8. I know I am an ‘Old F@rt but I would have given man of the match to Ashman, off the bench early doors with a couple of blokes possibly in front of him in the pecking order, he might get his chance again but he will never get the chance again to score on his debut AND get man of the match.
    Hamish Watson I am sure would have been just as happy to see that going to the debutant, I know I’m a soft touch for a fairy tale, but I don’t care.
    That said well done a few seasons ago we would have lost this type of fixture but well done to the lads a great team effort.
    Onward and upwards.

    • Was anyone counting the success of the boxkick/chase? I had it at 20% success, the rest of the time the receiving team made good use of it. When are coaches going to realise Faf d K has a particularly accurate kick and the SA chasers practised it nonstop leading up to the World Cup? Its not for every team.

      • I’ll take your figures at face value, however as I said it was the sort of game that in the past we would have lost and I praised the Team effort. A win is a win, and yes next week will be another level, I haven’t seen the Welsh game but by all accounts they seemed to hold there own reasonably well.

      • Faf won’t be playing. He’s out for while.
        Boks will still hoof it loads of course, but are depending more on Pollard to launch hail marys. neither Jantjies nor Reinbach kick nearly as well as Faf. Reinbach can’t half sprint though

Comments are closed.