#RWC2019: Five questions which will be answered in Japan

Who will return from the Land of the Rising Sun riding on the shoulders of giants? And who will slink home with tail between legs?

New Zealand win
Richie McCaw of New Zealand lifted the Word Cup four years ago, but who will get their hands on the trophy this tie round? Image: Fotosport/David Gibson
Savills

1. Which team will spring a surprise?

Last time out it was the Brave Blossoms who stunned the watching world by beating the Bokke, and deservedly so, although it meant they were on their knees when facing Scotland four days later.

In looking for the next giant killer there are a handful of potential candidates. Samoa in Scotland’s pool usually have one great game in them and they almost did for Vern Cotter’s side four years ago in Newcastle.

The USA will come fully loaded and may push Argentina or France in Pool 3. while perennial underdogs Fiji have enough natural talent to ruin the World Cup for either Wales or Australia.


This weekend’s Premiership match reports:

Marr v Musselburgh: hosts make heavy weather of it

Jed-Forest v Edinburgh Accies: depleted hosts take encouragement from defeat

Youth and experience combine as Currie Chieftains assert title credentials

Glasgow Hawks v Aberdeen Grammar: hosts jump start their season


2. Is this the year for a new World Cup winner?

In case you were in any doubt, the answer is almost certainly no. There have been four winners to date and New Zealand, South Africa and England remain the favourites to lift this cup with the Wallabies trailing behind in the bookies.

The amount of time and money, effort and expertise required to join the elite of the sport is prohibitive for any Johnny-come-lately, flash-in-the-pan side that enjoys a run of luck as can (occasionally) happen in footer.

There are only two and a half realistic newbies who could cart the trophy back to Europe –

  • Wales have a decent first choice forward pack and numerous game-breakers in the backs but probably lack the strength in depth to mount a challenge up front. Alun-Wyn will be on his knees if/when the Dragons get to a semi-final.
  • Ireland looked much like their old selves when hammering Wales last time out with the most basic of game plans even by Joe Schmidt standards but they don’t have the full court game.
  • And the half chance goes to France who already boast more menace now that Fabien Galthie, rather than Jacques Brunel, has the reins and is stamping his mark all over this team. Les Blues usually thrive come the World Cup regardless of how hopeless they have been in between times and the 33-1 against them for the silverware are the only odds even a little bit tempting.
Savills

3. Which referee is going to stuff it up this time?

A good official is an anonymous one and even Nigel can grate a bit now he is slow and prone to the odd howler. The World Cup has a habit of focusing the spotlight upon match officials largely thanks to the multitude of laws that are open to interpretation.

Craig Joubert did not cover himself in glory last time out when he made the wrong call in Australia’s favour by incorrectly penalising Scotland prop Jon Welsh in the quarter-finals.

Back in 2007, Wayne Barnes lost any Kiwi friends he may have had after taking a Nelsonian look at a French forward pass in the build up to a crucial try in that utterly unexpected quarter-final win over the Blacks and, while this wasn’t in a World Cup, Romain Poite interpreted the accidental offside law in a unique manner to ensure the B&I Lions drew the Test series with New Zealand in 2017. (Incidentally, wasn’t he correct? Shouldn’t an accidental offside, and it’s tough to ignore the ball when it flies towards you, result in a scrum rather than a penalty?)

Big in Japan: The Offside Line at RWC2019

4.  Might red cards win key matches or, to be more accurate, lose them?

All teams prepare to play with 14/13 men and you can see why with World Rugby holding the refs’ feet to the fire over any contact around the head area. Already two locks have had a question mark over their participation: France’s Paul Gabrillagues who had his six week ban halved, which brings him into line with Scott Barrett of the All Blacks who copped a three week sanction for a shoulder to Michael Hooper’s melon.

There can be no compromise when it comes to player safety but players are still on a steep learning curve and, in the heat of battle, desperately tight margins leave zero wriggle room for even miniscule errors of judgement.

If you fancy a wager, don’t be short red cards.

Savills

5. Who Will Own RWC’19?

Looking back over the years there has usually been one or two players whose name became firmly associated with each tournament.

1987: John Kirwan ran riot and through the entire Italy team, twice, to score a length of the field try.

1991: David Campese was the tournament top scorer but he slapped down an England scoring pass to help the Wallabies lift the Cup.

1995: Jonah Lomu announced his arrival on the world stage, although rugby’s first superstar was still shaded by Nelson Mandela in a Springbok shirt.

1999: French flyhalf Christophe Lamaison orchestrated the greatest RWC comeback ever seen, against New Zealand no less.

2003: Jonny Wilkinson became a global superstar by dropping England to glory off his wrong peg.

2007: The Springboks’ fielded a centre the size of a lock, Frans Steyn made his name in France.

2011: The irrepressible Piri Weepu eased the nervy All Blacks’ into the final but it was Stephen Donald whodropped his fishing rod to kick the winning points.

2015: Japan’s classy full-back Ayumu Goromaru stole the show four years ago in England, Tommy Seymour still doesn’t know what hit him?

2019: ?


Of course, rest and recuperation is key in international rugby so who does the draw help/hinder?


Just for fun … foreign born players –

19: Samoa…Kiwis by birth, Samoan by ancestry.

16: Tonga…see above

15: USA … including four Irishmen and four South Africans

15; Japan … including five Kiwis and thee South Africans.

14: Scotland (although Johns Barclay was born in Hong Kong he came through the domestic Scottish system)

12: Australia … including four Fijians.

8: Italy & Wales … all sorts with Italy, and English-born Welshmen for Wales

7: England … including two Vunipolas, one Tuilangi and one Cokanasigna, all three with Pacific Island ancestry

5: France … including Algerian-born Sofiane Guitoune

4: Fiji, New Zealand & Canada … who boast Scottish half-back Gordy McCrorie

1: Georgia, Russia & South Africa … who boast the “Beast” from Zim.

0: Congrats to Argentina, Namibia & Uruguay … who produce all their own players.

Savills


And finally … OUR WORLD BEATERS XV … who won’t be in Japan!

15. Damien McKenzie

One day the brilliant Kiwi will light up the World Cup, just not this one.

14. Santiago Cordero

Los Pumas must have some handy wingers if they can overlook this livewire.

13.  Ben Te’o

Fisty McFighty is unwanted by England for some odd reason?

12. Ngani Laumape

Excess to the All Blacks despite being the same size as a small rhino and about as easy to halt.

11. Waisake Naholo.

It is possible he burnt his bridges by joining London Irish for the coming season.

10. Gareth Anscombe

Injured in the warm up, although Dan Bigger is a pretty handy replacement.

9. Danny Care

Overlooked for Kiwi Willy Heinz and none too pleased about it either.

1. Rob Evans

Short of a gallop after injury issues. May yet feature.

2. Dylan Hartley

Injured, overlooked and over the hill.

3. Owen Franks

Unlucky, but perhaps the All Black centurion and scrum anchor is too quiet about the field.

4. Richie Gray

Constant injury issues have knocked the competitive stuffing out of big Richie who misses his last realistic World Cup chance.

5. Devin Toner

Overlooked in favour of South African “project” Jean Kleyn, which has caused an almighty stink across the water.

6. Brad Shields

Unwanted by the Blacks and now overlooked by England.

7. Facundo Isa

An odd decision since Los Pumas haven’t exactly knocked it out the ball park without their foreign mercenaries.

8 Taulupe Faletau

Had he been fit we might have fancied Wales to do something special. But he isn’t. So we don’t.

The Offside Line is ready for its biggest and best season yet

We hope you’ve enjoyed reading this article

Support our new, improved coverage this season 2019-20, with Super 6, National 1 and 2 leagues, fixtures and tables, and the small matter of our comprehensive coverage of Scotland at the RWC from Japan.

Invest in our gameyou can make a difference by keeping Scottish rugby at all levels in the news.

Savills
Iain Morrison
About Iain Morrison 6 Articles
Iain was capped 15 times for Scotland at openside flanker between his debut against Ireland during the 1993 Six Nations and his final match against New Zealand at the 1995 World Cup in South Africa. He was twice a Cambridge ‘Blue’ and played his entire club career with London Scottish (being inducted into the club’s Hall of Fame in 2016). Iain is a lifelong member of Linlithgow Rugby Club. After hanging up his boots, he became rugby correspondent for The Sunday Herald, before moving to The Scotland on Sunday for 16 years, and he has also guest written for various other publications.

5 Comments

  1. Whilst I would agree with your comment about Nigel Owen’s powers waning in recent times, I would query the wisdom of referring to someone, who as recently as June 2018 openly discussed his ongoing battle with bulimia nervoso, as ‘porky’.

    • Your point is well made and we have taken it on board. Thank you. No offence was meant to anyone struggling with an eating disorder.

    • Sorry Paul. Ireland have 5 foreign born players. Two Saffas in the pack while Carbery and Aki were NZ born. Luke McGrath is the 5th man…born in Canada I think and how they could have done with him over the last few years.

  2. As a fan the most destructive force on the field is an incompetent referee. Unfortunately at present most of them seem to be French. The all blacks wallabies game in Perth Barrett was red carded for his indiscretion but the referee did nothing about the wallabies neck rolling players out of the ruck. Where is the consistency

Comments are closed.