Premiership Team-of-the-Week for Round Four

Three Kelso players make this week's selection with a few others unlucky to miss out

Frankie Robson earns a place in the centre for this week's Dream Team after leading Kelso to their first victory since returning to the Premiership against Glasgow Hawks at Poyner Park. Image: Charles Brooker
Frankie Robson earns a place in the centre for this week's Dream Team after leading Kelso to their first victory since returning to the Premiership against Glasgow Hawks at Poyner Park. Image: Charles Brooker

AFTER two draws, Kelso picked up their first win since returning to the Premiership this season after two decades away, and full-back Archie Barbour is one of three Poynder Park men to gain selection for this week’s Dream Team, while two or three more can consider themselves unlucky to have missed out.

He is joined in the back-three by Jack Scott, who scored two tries in Marr’s home win over Selkirk, and Robbie Shirra-Gibb, who showed up well for Jed in a home loss against Musselburgh, which means Finlay MacNeill is a hard luck story following a promising performance both sides of the ball on his first Edinburgh Accies start.

There was plenty of competition in the centre, with the Bickerstaff boys – Scott and Conor – as usual, making strong cases for selection, as did Kelso duo Frankie Robson and James Thompson, and Andrew Mitchell of Hawick. Ultimately, the elder Bickerstaff and Robson edged selection.


2023 Super Series Championship: Round Eight Dream Team

RWC23: Scotland v Romania: Johnny Matthews call-up is ideal end to great summer

Ayr cash their chips in with Albert Bartlett


Jamie Forbes pulled the strings as Currie Chieftains put Heriot’s Blues to the sword at Malleny Park so is selected ahead of fellow perennial Dream Team contender Colin Sturgeon of Marr at stand-off. It was a tight call at scrum-half between Robbie Baird making his debut for Marr and Patrick Ritchie of Edinburgh Accies, and the latter just edging it.

Shawn Muir was immense at scrum time which laid the platform for Hawick’s home win over Edinburgh Accies so he is at loose-head, with Bob Stott of Musselburgh gets the nod over Roy Vucago of Currie Chieftains at hooker and Zen Szwagrzak came off the bench to solidify the Selkirk scrum and also scored his team’s bonus point try in a busy performance in the loose so he is at tight-head.

Two-try Ali McCallum of Currie Chieftains is unlucky to miss out on a spot in the engine-room, as is Cameron Bain of Edinburgh Accies and Calum Folan of Marr, but Keith Melbourne of Kelso and hat-trick hero Michael Badenhorst of Musselburgh were impossible to overlook after abrasive and industrious afternoon’s for their respective teams.

As always, there was plenty of competition in the back-row, too, with Innes Hill of Heriot’s Blues in at blindside, Sam Cardosi of Currie Chieftains at openside and the explosive Jae Linton of Hawick is at No 8, while Bruce McNeill of Kelso, Jamie Sole of Edinburgh Accies, Blake Roff of Jed-Forest and Blair Jardine of Marr were all recommended in that position

 

15. Archie Barbour (Kelso)

 

14. Jack Scott (Marr)

13. Scott Bickerstaff (Marr)

12. Frankie Robson (Kelso)

11. Robbie Shirra-Gibb (Jed-Forest)

 

10. Jamie Forbes (Currie Chieftains)

9. Patrick Ritchie (Edinburgh Accies)

 

1. Shawn Muir (Hawick)

2. Robert Stott (Musselburgh)

3. Zen Szwagrzak (Selkirk)

4. Keith Melbourne (Kelso)

5. Michael Badenhorst (Musselburgh)

6. Innes Hill (Heriot’s)

7. Sam Cardosi (Currie Chieftains)

8. Jae Linton (Hawick) 


RWC23: TOL’s World Cup team-of-the-Week – third round of pool matches

About David Barnes 3821 Articles
David has worked as a freelance rugby journalist since 2004 covering every level of the game in Scotland for publications including he Herald/Sunday Herald, The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The Scotsman/Scotland on Sunday/Evening News, The Daily Record, The Daily Mail/Mail on Sunday and The Sun.