Premiership: Selkirk sweep past Jed-Forest in Philiphaugh try-fest

Hosts score 10 tries to visitors' five for first win of the campaign

The impressive Andrew McColm on the charge for Selkirk versus Jed-Forest. Image: Grant Kinghorn
The impressive Andrew McColm on the charge for Selkirk versus Jed-Forest. Image: Grant Kinghorn

Selkirk 65

Jed-Forest 35

ALAN LORIMER @ Philiphaugh

IN the nuclear industry they talk about neutron flux: today this was a points flux – the full tonne, in fact – in a bizarre match where the losers scored five tries but still lost by 30 points to a Selkirk side that at last found their mojo after a difficult start to the Premiership season.

You had to focus really hard on play to keep track of the tries, such was the pace of scoring that resulted in a rate of more than a point a minute, adding up to an entertaining spectacle. So often it is said of a game that defences were on top: not so at Philiphaugh where this game was all about playing attacking rugby, that certainly was to the liking of the home coach, Gordon Henderson, who watched his charges construct some excellent tries.

“We put some really good attacks together and the interplay between backs and forwards was excellent,” reflected Henderson. “We scored some good tries. Our work rate off the ball was better this week.

RWC23: ‘He sent the whole pack over the top, just to shoe me out the way and out the other side’

RWC23: Stuart McInally hunts happy ending to distinguished Scotland career

Hawick kick-off 150th celebrations this weekend with mural unveiling and re-enactment match

“Scoring 65 points is hard against any team and Jed defended well at times, but once we went through the phases we scored some good tries. The pleasing thing was that once we got into the right areas we scored.”

The win and especially by such a big margin certainly cheered the Philiphaugh faithful as Henderson acknowledged. He said: “It’s been a hard shift the last couple of weeks. We needed that win today – I said to the lads to take the emotion out of the local derby and to go out there and put a good performance in with high work rate and physicality.”

Selkirk can certainly congratulate themselves on many good aspects of their performance, and notably the desire to use run into space and move the ball rather than deploy bulldozer tactics. In which context No 8 Andrew McColm impressed with both his soft hands and his role as a link player.

Behind the scrum, Selkirk’s backline had a fluency which Jed manifestly lacked. The key to this was the centre pairing of Andrew Grant-Suttie and veteran Ross Nixon, the latter always on hand to offer guidance to young stand-off Cameron Easson, who posted a competent performance.

For Jed, there should have been joy at scoring five tries but conceding twice that number rather changed their complexion. Jed’s woes this season have not been helped by having little consistency in the composition of their back division, affecting not only their attacking capability but more crucially their ability to contain the opposition

Jed’s coach, David Grieve, was quick to concede this deficiency, saying: “The big problem for us today was our defence. It wasn’t good enough, at the end of the day. We gave away some soft tries. It was just too easy for them at times. But it’s fixable. Little tweaks here and there”.

It was not all gloom for Jed, however. “We scored 35 points so we’re not far away. At least it’s our first championship point, and last season it took us four games to reach that mark,” pointed out Grieve.

The tenor of the match was set in the opening minute when Callum Anderson raced in for the opening try to give Selkirk the early lead. An Easson penalty and then a Grant-Suttie try added to Selkirk’s points tally but, meanwhile, Jed had shown their attacking prowess with an Elliot Lauder close-range effort followed by a touchdown from 17-year-old Mark Glen and then a Clark Skeldon score, all three converted by Gary Munro to put Jed into a 21-15 lead with 25 minute played.

But then Selkirk scored a gem of a try made by Anderson’s ability to pirouette out of the tackle followed by a link up with Andrew McColm. Fellow back-row Scott McClymont then worked a clever move round the front of a line-out to regain the lead and collect a bonus point for Selkirk before Aaron McColm finished off good work by Josh Welsh for a 32-21 half time lead.


Youngster Finlay Wheelans extended Selkirk’s lead just after the break only for Jed to hit back with a Lauder touchdown for the bonus point. Selkirk countered with a try for prop Jake Millburn on his debut for the club and when Wheelans ran in for his second score Selkirk hit the half century.

Jed, however, found their way to score in reply, as Robbie Shirra-Gibb ran on to the ball at full pace before sprinting to the line, Munro making it five from five with the conversion.

Welsh then added to the Selkirk pile of points, amplified by a rather easy interception score from second row Andrew Cochrane to complete a sumptuous win for the Philiphaugh men.


Teams –

Selkirk: C Anderson; J Welsh, A Grant-Suttie, R Nixon, F Wheelans; C Easson, Aaron McColm; L Pettie, F Easson, J Millburn, A Cochrane, C Ward, D Nichol, S McClymont©, Andrew McColm. Subs: J Bett, C Turnbull, J Turnbull, A Penman, B Cullen.

Jed-Forest: M Glen; L Elder, L Walker, O Cranston, R Shirra-Gibb; G Munro, A Bambrick; R Briggs, J Ferguson, H Meadows, C Skeldon©, B Hope, D Wardrop, J Howe, B Roff. Subs: M Weekley,J Story, J Hynd, E Lauder, S Murdoch.

Referee: Calum Worsley


Scorers –

Selkirk: Tries: Anderson, Grant-Suttie, Andrew McColm, McClymont, Aaron McColm, Wheelans 2, Millburn, Welsh, Cochrane; Cons: Easson 5, Anderson; Pen: Easson.

Jed-Forest: Tries: Lauder 2, Glen, Skeldon, Shirra-Gibb; Cons: Munro 5.

Scoring Sequence (Selkirk first): 5-0, 5-5, 5-7, 8-7, 13-7, 15-7, 15-12, 15-14, 15-19, 15-21, 20-21, 25-21, 30-21, 32-21 (h-t) 37-21, 39-21, 39-26, 39-28, 44-28, 46-28, 51-28, 51-33, 51-35, 56-35, 58-35, 63-35, 65-35


Man-of-the-Match: Selkirk had a number of candidates including Andrew McColm, Andrew Grant-Suttie and Josh Welsh but just edging ahead was full-back Callum Anderson, whose left foot kicking had both length and accuracy and whose skilful running was key to the try production line.

Talking point: Selkirk could afford a minor celebration after their win but they know that future Premiership wins will not come as easy as the victory of a Jed side that was deficient in defence. But Selkirk will be pleased at the performance of youngsters Cameron Easson and Finlay Wheelans and the overall commitment of the team to play attacking and clever rugby.  For Jed there will have to be a rapid regrouping and a concerted effort to work out how to fix the weakness in defence.

RWC23: ‘He sent the whole pack over the top, just to shoe me out the way and out the other side’

About Alan Lorimer 339 Articles
Scotland rugby correspondent for The Times for six years and subsequently contributed to Sunday Times, Daily and Sunday Telegraph, Scotsman, Herald, Scotland on Sunday, Sunday Herald and Reuters. Worked in Radio for BBC. Alan is Scottish rugby journalism's leading voice when it comes to youth and schools rugby.


  1. I’m a Jed exile, and not quite up to speed with all that’s been happening pre-season etc.
    Can anyone bring me up to speed here, why the issue with lack of Jed players I.e. a boy of 17 playing men’s rugger but credit to him for scoring a try, so an hour bivouac talent👍
    It’s going to be a long hard season for Jed if they don’t get some experience on the pitch.
    Any feedback on Jed’s 1st team squad would be welcome, TQ 🙂

Comments are closed.