Premiership: Musselburgh push league leaders Hawick all the way

League's bottom side pick up a valuable losing bonus-point and show they have what it takes to survive in this league

Colin Arthur carries the ball for Musselburgh against Hawick. Image: John Durham
Colin Arthur carries the ball for Musselburgh against Hawick. Image: John Durham

Musselburgh 14

Hawick 20

FINN TAIT @ Stoneyhill

HAWICK delivered a dogged performance to ultimately silence a Musselburgh side that showed heart and character in their fight against relegation. In tough conditions, the Borderers capitalised on Musselburgh misfortune to take a tight win and extend their unbeaten run to 12 match and extend their lead at the top of the table.

“Conditions played a big part today, I am happy with how we weathered the storm but I feel at times we didn’t play to the conditions and invited pressure onto ourselves,” said victorious coach Matty Douglas.

“Credit to Musselburgh, they really stuck in, I am just happy we managed to take the points away from home. It was a real dogfight and with so many changes they were always going to be a tough side and it was good for us to be in a game like this.”

Premiership: Edinburgh Accies snatch dramatic late win over Currie Chieftains

Benetton v Edinburgh: visitors flop against 14-man Italians

Premiership: fit again Aidan Bambrick ready to push on with Jed-Forest

Musselburgh came out the gate full of fire, dominating the early exchanges with Paul Bogie and Neil McNairn leading the charge. The hosts built strongly and had the try-line within sight before a wayward pass was smartly collected by Kirk Ford and allowed Hawick to clear.

Off the resultant line-out Hawick kicked waywardly allowing James Ferguson to return a thunderous 50-22 that glanced off the corner flag protector. A smart line-out move allowed Edinburgh Rugby academy player Jamie Campbell to dive over to score, rewarding Musselburgh’s early pressure.

The physicality of the Musselburgh team was vicious in the early exchanges with several Hawick salvos being shutdown at source. Fearsome tackles in midfield were exchanged by the two centre pairings with neither side able to capitalise on field position due the line speed and brutality of the hits.

This period of deadlock was broken by the Musselburgh front-row, who produced a huge scrum allowing Danny Owenson a penalty shot at goal. He duly converted stretching the Musselburgh lead to eight points.

Hawick’s defensive rock, Andrew Mitchell, switched caps to lead the charge in attack taking Hawick inside the 22. Owenson was sent to the bin for cynical play and Ford converted took the three points.

But Musselburgh didn’t allow being man down to dent their enthusiasm, and Hawick were punished for indiscipline in the contact area which allowed stand-in kicker Paul Cunningham to restore Musselburgh’s lead.

The pendulum then swung Hawick’s way and they made their man advantage pay, utilising their tactical kicking to keep Musselburgh pinned deep in their half, and when visiting stand-off Kyle Brunton to Mitchell, the rampaging centre Mitchell escaped the challenge of opposite number Rory Watt and thundered over the top of the despairing cover defence to level the scores. The metronomic boot of Ford converted, and Hawick brought themselves within a point.

Owenson, fresh out the bin, wasted no time steadying his side, placing some exquisite box-kicks to march Musselburgh down into the Hawick 22, and the home team had a maul held up over the try-line.


The second half started frantically with both sides having early line-breaks, the robust figure of Michael Badenhorst making in-rouds for the hosts and Gareth Welsh nearly escaping down the touch line for the visitors.

Hawick were first to bother the scoreboard operator in the second half, Ford capitalising on some smart work at the breakdown from captain Matt Carryer to hand Hawick the lead.

In response, Owenson again brought his forwards onto the ball nicely with Badenhorst and the returning Max Outram working tirelessly. Owenson also tried a cheeky chip over the top which would’ve seen Rory Watt in for a score but the winger could not gather.

Brunton cleared and Hawick took control with Ronan McKean making good metres down the touchline, before the visiting forwards earned their team a penalty which allowed Ford to go for the corner, but the Greens were thwarted by Campbell’s aerial excellence, pinching the ball five metres short of his own line.

Hawick’s pressure cooker continued, drawing several penalties, and Musselburgh eventually lost Craig Owenson to the bin. Handbags ensued and there was a murmur of discontent among the home fans who believed they were hard done by.

A powerful Hawick scrum provided an ideal platform for Brunton’s backs to capitalise and with several miss-passes the ball found its way to Lewis Ferguson who finished in the corner. Ford claimed the extras from the touchline.

Musselburgh were unlucky again, the team showing tremendous heart and fight. Even with 14 men they posed a threat to the line and looked to be inching closer before Badenhorst lost control in the process of another thunderous carry.

This pressure led to a card for the away side against second-row Daniel Suddon for coming in at the side. But the hosts could not capitalise on their pressure. Finn Duraj fresh off the bench provided the best chance of the half, bursting down the touchline evading defenders before being shut down by the covering Ford.

Hawick’s Ross Graham saw yellow for a dangerous tackle which gave Owenson a chance to take Musselburgh within a score, and Musselburgh the chance of an unlikely win against 13 men, but Hawick . controlled the final few minutes and the home team and had to settle for a losing bonus point.

“We deserved a lot more out of that game,” said Musselburgh coach Derek O’Riordan. “This is the standard we should expect at this point following the corner we turned in advance of playing Marr. We’ve shown twice now that we can go toe-to-toe with the big boys in the league.”


Teams –

Musselburgh: R Young; J Ferguson, F Thomson, R Watt, S Watt; P Cunningham, D Owenson; C Owenson, B Stott, N McNairn; J Campbell, W Fleming, M Badenhorst, M Outram, P Bogie. Subs: F Duraj, C Arthur, J Lister, C Champion, F Call

Hawick: K Ford; L Ferguson, E Reilly, A Mitchell, R McKean; K Brunton, G Welsh; S Muir, M Carryer©, N Little, D Suddon, S Fairbairn, C Sutherland, C Renwick, S Graham. Subs: R Graham, T Hope, D Redpath, H Patterson, L Gordon-Woolley.

Referee: Fergus Hollins


Scorers –

Musselburgh: Tries: Campbell; Cons:  Pens: Owenson 2, Cunningham

Hawick: Tries: Mitchell, L Ferguson; Cons: Ford 2; Pens: Ford 2.

Scoring sequence (Musselburgh first): 5-0; 8-0; 8-3; 8-8; 8-10; 11-10 (h-t) 11-13; 11-18; 11-20; 14-20.


Yellow cards –

Musselburgh: D Owenson (25mins), C Owenson (55mins)

Hawick: Suddon (70mins), R Graham (75mins)

Man-of-the-Match: The work-rate and effort shown by the whole Hawick back-row was excellent, but Calum Renwick was the pick of the bunch. His contribution was a big part of the reason why Hawick were able to grind out the win.

Talking point: Hawick will take the points, but Musselburgh confirmed today that they belong in this league. If they continue the effort levels and willingness to front up which they showed today, they will take the relegation battle deep into the season.

Premiership: Edinburgh Accies snatch dramatic late win over Currie Chieftains

About Finn Tait 12 Articles
Finn is a recent graduate from the University of Aberdeen in Politics and International Relations. He has over 10 years of rugby experience playing at School and University 1st XV level, as well as regional involvement.


  1. Accept hawicks lights not great and need upgrade. However yesterday’s game was no playable in last 10min. When will the SRU actually run a proper premiership. With clubs having to meet
    A criterion to play at this level. I made this very clear.

    • Nobody will be playing under lights soon .
      Most teams will want to play earlier in daylight due to exsorbitant costs of floodlights .

  2. Perhaps as used to happen the home team could use a change of strip to make a more visual difference between teams. Yesterday it was only Musselburgh’s red socks that identified them in the last quarter. A tough game hampered by a strong wind with little between the teams. Exciting stuff nonetheless.

  3. When will the SRU insist that teams playing in the premiership. Meet certain ground criteria. No flood lights at Musselburgh. They played well enough, but flood lights a basic at this level of competition.
    It is the only premiership in the world were there is no criteria for playing at this level.

    • FYI Musselburgh were the first club in Scotland to have flood lights. It was not deemed necessary to use them today. It was windy not dark.

    • Creiky Keith Hawick’s lights are the worst in the country mun. 😎
      Musselburgh have lights and good ones at that.

    • State of the nation just now .sensible to play earlier for more daylight
      Soon no club will be able to pay the electric bill for floodlights .

  4. I think Jed will come up to their home ground in 2 weeks time and put the fairytale story to an end.


Comments are closed.