Premiership: Edinburgh Accies blow Jed-Forest away in the second half

Hosts score four tries in 20 minute period after the break to take the game away from struggling Borderers

Tom Drennan scored for Edinburgh Accies versus Jed-Forest. Image: John Wright
Tom Drennan scored for Edinburgh Accies versus Jed-Forest. Image: John Wright

Edinburgh Accies 57

Jed-Forest 14

IAIN MORRISON @ Raeburn Place

THIS was a game of completely contrasting halves. In the opening 40 we had a competitive and intriguing rugby match on our hands. While Accies looked the better side they led at the break by just 21 points to 14, three tries to two. In the second half the floodgates opened and Accies filled their boots, running in an additional five touchdowns, four of which arrived in a third quarter deluge that effectively ended the game.

Accies certainly upped their game but Jed will be worried at their near total capitulation after the break when they failed to add to their score.

In the first half Accies played too much rugby inside their own 22. It was obviously part of the game plan but it equally obviously didn’t really work because too many passes were spilled, handing the ball and the initiative back to the visitors

URC: Glasgow v Stormers: Warriors win but second half slump means no bonus point

Super Series: Euan Muirhead eyes strong end to Boroughmuir Bears’ campaign

Super Series: Late Heriot’s score kills Southern Knights’ play-off dream

Robbie Chalmers was involved in most of Accies best plays. He provides pace and nous from full-back and his delicate little chip kicks sowed confusion amongst the Jed defenders. More than once he simply had too much pace for the Jed cover.

Meanwhile, fly-half Ben Appleson kicked immaculately off the tee, registering 100 percent in front of goal, claiming 17 points thanks to seven conversions and the only penalty of the game (with the only missed conversion of the match was by Accies’ replacement Patrick Ritchie).

Accies opened the scoring after just 10 minutes of action and only after Jed had turned down an easy three in favour of the attacking line-out which came to nothing. Accies did the same at the opposite end of the field but they made it stick. The home side won the line-out thanks to Tom Drennan, drove the maul and hooker Grant Hall was the last man up with the ball.

Accies used the exact same ploy on the opposite side of the field for their third try of the afternoon, this one falling to flanker Kieran Slingsby who, according to his mates in the Accies bar, also made four turnovers in the game.

In between these two scores, Accies flanker Ted Jones added the second try from close range after winger Kerr Gossman was stopped short.

Despite their insistence on running the ball from all corners of the field it was the driving maul that provided two of Accies three first half scores.

For their part Jed had taken a leaf out of Accies playbook and the Borderers threw the ball about Barbarians’ style, if not always with Barbarians’ accuracy. They went left, right, left again to create space on the flank for winger Robbie Shirra-Gibb to canter home from 20 metres out and he didn’t even need the spare man outside him.

That score breathed life into the visiting team who then won a scrum penalty despite the fact that this was Jamie Ferguson’s first stint as a loose-head prop, having previously turned out as a hooker.

Jed were fiercely competitive in the first half, none more so than scrum-half Aidan Bambrick who harried his opposite number Ben Grainger into an error at the base of the scrum. It looked like the Jed nine intercepted Grainger’s pass with his boot and was first to pounce on the ball in no man’s land.


Accies took a nervy 21-14 lead into the half time dressing room where head coach Iain Berthinussen presumably gave them a dressing down because what followed bore absolutely no relationship with what we had already witnessed as the hosts started the second half with an intensity and intent that had been largely absent from much of the first 40.

“To be honest, I was going to say something but the players beat me to it,” said the Accies coach. “They understood that the first half is not what we are about.

“What I did tell them was that while Jed are struggling they still have a lot of very good players and we needed to respect that and play accordingly. And I think we did that after the break.”

Indeed they did. Accies scored 31 unanswered points, four converted tries and a penalty, in the third quarter which ended the game as a contest.

First up, Chris Thomson carried four or five royal blue shirts over the try line as the Accies No 8 scored far too easily. Then the tight-head prop Calum Crookshanks burrowed over from short range and lock Drennan did the same thing in the exact same spot.

With their tails up, Accies piled more misery on Jed-Forest shoulders. Winger Gossman was denied a try in the left corner when Applseson’s cross kick bounced unkindly for him but he struck soon enough, popping up in midfield to find a gap and touching down under the sticks.

In the space of 20 minutes Accies had stretched a seven point lead into a 38 point advantage that they never looked like losing. In the final quarter of the match, Grainger scored Accies’ eighth try of the afternoon after Chalmers made all the running.

With the game long gone, Jed actually muscled the ball over Accies’ try line … only for the referee to declare that it had been held up. An afternoon to forget for the Borderers who remain winless this season and only managed to scrape together 18 fit players for this trip to Edinburgh..

“I thought we were very competitive for the first half,” said a shell shocked coach David Grieve. “We defended well and I thought our structure was good too.

“It seems like we have to have a lull in every game we play and this afternoon it was in the second half. It’s difficult to know why the players seem to wilt, and you can see the result for yourself. It’s very difficult but you have to keep trying.”


Teams – 

Edinburgh Accies: R Chalmers; F MacNeill, N Armstrong (Capt), G Woods, K Gossman; B Appleson, B Grainger; C Imrie, G Hall, C Crookshank, T Drennan, S Whittaker, T Jones, K Slingby, C Thomson. Substitutes: F McAslan, A Hain, M Walker, P Richie, J Jones.

Jed-Forest:  M Glen; B Irvine, R Marshall, L Elder, R Shirra-Gibb; G Munro, A Bambrick, J Ferguson, H Keith; H Meadows, C Skeldon, J Hynd, D Wardrop, B Roff, B Fotheringham. Substitutes: H Stenhouse, N Bates, A Hendrie.

Referee: Fergus Hollins.


Scorers – 

Edinburgh Accies: Tries: Hall, Jones, Slingsby, Thomson, Crookshank, Drennan, Gossman, Grainger; Cons: Appleson 7;  Pen: Appleson.

Jed-Forest: Tries: Shirra-Gibb, A Bambrick; Cons: Buckley 2.

Sequence of scoring (Edinburgh Accies first): 5-0; 7-0; 12-0; 14-0; 14-5; 14-7; 19-7; 21-7; 21-12; 21-14. (h-t) 26-14; 28-14; 31-14; 36-14; 38-14; 43-14; 45-14; 50-14; 52-14; 57-14.


Man-of-the-Match: Ben Applseson kicked everything he was asked to and kicked well from hand, if not quite enough in that first half. Hooker Grant Hall grabbed a try and looked lively in the loose and Kieran Slingby did well at the breakdown, but the award goes to Robbie Chalmers who was a constant threat from full-back.

Talking point: In the final few minutes of the match, Jed scrummy Adian Bambrick was struggling with cramp in his calves and his opposite number Ben Grainger came to his rescue, stretching the muscle for the Jed man. In a game that was occasionally fractious it was nice to see the old values still hold sway.

Alpha Whisky and My Name’5 Doddie Foundation team-up for unique club rugby offer

About Iain Morrison 133 Articles
Iain was capped 15 times for Scotland at openside flanker between his debut against Ireland during the 1993 Six Nations and his final match against New Zealand at the 1995 World Cup in South Africa. He was twice a Cambridge ‘Blue’ and played his entire club career with London Scottish (being inducted into the club’s Hall of Fame in 2016). Iain is a lifelong member of Linlithgow Rugby Club. After hanging up his boots, he became rugby correspondent for The Sunday Herald, before moving to The Scotland on Sunday for 16 years, and he has also guest written for various other publications.


  1. Bye bye Jed. Would love to say you’ll be missed but I highly doubt it. Can see this being a relegation this year followed by a few years of free falling because things will never change.

    • Coco.
      Too much reliance on certain players with too much influence .
      Vastly Overrated .but you try telling them that
      Brutal observation but that’s the truth
      That’s the cause of Jed’s free fall .

      Too late now the damage is done.

    • Sounds like you’ve lost the argument, another Jed man that’s a Jed hater. We have too many of them so you’ll have to join the back of the Q

      • Lost the argument? You sure about that?!

        Look a lot closer to home if you’re looking for people to blame for the predicament. To put some of the blame on lads like Slingsby or anyone else that leaves (or never really played) is utterly pathetic

  2. Kieran Slingby a Jed man opting to play for city side Accies as his home club struggles week in week out is a sin in my eyes

    • What’s Gary Armstrong doing these days ?
      How they could do with a player like that .
      Jed rugby is in turmoil.
      We could all see what was happening the last few seasons but nothing was done about it.
      Now it’s too late

      • Nail on head Colin, a fish rots from the head down. Leadership and communication from the top has been non existent and until they look in the mirror Jed’s woes will continue.
        The Thistle produce plenty talented rugby players, it’s high time the main club got their act together before they are a nonentity.

    • Wind it in. Has the lad even played for Jed before?

      Went to Edinburgh as a young buck and chooses not to drive 50 odd miles 3 times a week. 50 miles to lose by 50 points? Naw, yer awright thanks

      To pin any blame on him for Jed’s current woes is p1sh poor. Bet you wouldn’t say it to his face in the Co-op or Cannon, the same as you wouldn’t have said anything when Aimo went to Gala and won Scottish Cup and Melrose 7s, or to Ronnie when he went to Boroughmuir

      • Yes he has played for Jed before.
        Not putting the blame on anyone but you say travel 50 odd miles when his flat mate Dan Wardrop(Jed’s player of the season so far I’d say) travels all week and yes he gets paid for the petrol, but that man has heart for Jed.
        We are talking in the current no need to bring amo or the likes


Comments are closed.