Hawick v Melrose: pack power proves decisive for hosts – with video highlights

Mansfield men book place in the first round of the cup with workmanlike win over Border rivals as head coach George Graham demands better

Hawick came out on top against Melrose in Scottish Cup preliminary round tie at Mansfield Park. Image: Kenny Baillie

Hawick 19

Melrose 3

ALAN LORIMER @ Mansfield Park

HAWICK progressed to the first round of the Scottish Cup after defeating Melrose in the preliminary round match at Mansfield Park. However, despite this ultimately being a comfortable win for the Greens, there is still much to do for George Graham’s side if it is to prosper in their Premiership campaign, which kicks-off with a tricky trip to Musselburgh next Saturday.

“It was a poor game and I’m bitterly disappointed that we made so many unforced errors,” said Graham. “Our discipline was terrible at times with silly penalties given away. We played a little bit better in the second half. It will evolve and we’ll get better and we’ll get a lot more competitive. It doesn’t matter what Melrose team you’re facing there always going to be combatative. And given the average age of these boys they were actually pretty good.

“We didn’t control the game because we couldn’t keep hold of the ball for long enough. We scrummaged very well today but I thought Melrose did so as well,” he added.

Georgia v Scotland: mission accomplished in Tbilisi

Edinburgh v London Scottish: new boys step up in comfortable home win

Scotland Women add Wales and Japan matches to Autumn schedule

What Hawick showed was their power up front, albeit this made for less of a rugby spectacle than the fans at Mansfield Park might have hoped for. Indeed for the first ten minutes of the second half Hawick played endless one-pass rugby that kept a lid on the excitement level.

For their part, Melrose will take much from this game, not least their ability to stand up to a very physical Hawick pack which contained three McNeils in the starting team, making you almost believe you were watching Barra in action.

“Both individually and collectively we got the performances we were looking for,” said Stuart Johnson, the Melrose coach. “We were up against a powerful Hawick side and we ran them close. Some of the defensive sets we put together were great. The scoreline didn’t reflect the game. We had a try disallowed and that was a massive turning point in the game.”

Despite dominating territory and possession Hawick took 17 minutes before putting points on the board from a try by flanker Stuart Graham, after the Greens forward pack had shunted the visitors’ eight backwards.

Then, against the run of play, Melrose gained ground from a massive touch-finder from David Colvine. An overthrow by Hawick at the ensuing line-out gave Melrose possession and a chance to attack. Lewis Mallin did the damage before the winger passed inside to the supporting Chris Raymond, allowing the back-row to touch down.

Melrose joy was short-lived, however, as referee Keith Allen disallowed the try on the basis of an earlier infringement, that only the most keen-eyed had spotted.


There was some compensation for Melrose in the form of a penalty goal by Colvine after Hawick were judged to be offside.

But any hopes that this represented a Melrose fightback quickly vanished when Hawick struck again two minutes before the break. A penalty kick to touch by stand-off Bailey Donaldson gave Hawick the perfect attacking platform and allowed the Greens power men to drive at the line, ending with hooker Matt Carryer smashing his way over to score under the posts, leaving aLI Weir with a simple conversion kick.

As they had done in the first half Hawick, took time to strike: 15 minutes, in fact. And again it was their powerful forwards that did the damage with multiple phases of one pass rugby that eventually wore down the Melrose defence allowing Daniel Suddon to exploit space and skipper Shawn Muir to finish the move off with an unconverted try.

Teams –

Hawick: A Weir; R McKean, A Mitchell, G Johnstone, L Gordon-Woolley; B Donaldson, G Welsh; S Muir, M Carryer, C Bachurzewski, K McNeil, D Suddon, S Graham, Billy McNeil, Bruce McNeil. Subs: C Renwick, D Johnstone, J Rowley, M Renwick, M Bannerman.

Melrose: K Clark; L Mallin, D Colvine, T Klein, J Brown; Donald Crawford, Douglas Crawford; W Owen, R Ferguson, C Crookshank, T Brown, C Wilde, C Raymond, G Runciman, T Andrews. Subs: B McLean, M Wilson, G Lindsay, S Fisher, G Wood.

Referee: K Allen


Scorers –

Hawick: Tries: Graham, Carryer, Muir; Cons Weir 2.

Melrose: Pen: Colvine.

Scoring Sequence (Hawick first): 5-0; 7-0; 7-3; 12-3; 14-3 (h-t) 19-3


Yellow cards –

Hawick: Graham

Man-of-the-Match: Melrose flanker Chris Raymond was a stand-out in the two Kings of the Sevens tournaments at Peebles and Hawick and has brought the same dynamic play into the fifteens game. He should be a huge asset to Melrose in National One this season.

Talking point: Hawick are working with a small squad this season but they still have the core of their forward pack from last year. The power they can generate will be vital for Hawick in the Premiership but the Greens will want to convince themselves that they have a backline game. That was certainly missing yesterday. But with a young stand-off in Bailey Donaldson still feeling his way in senior rugby, Hawick will surely develop a dynamic game behind the scrum.

  • Full round-ups of both Scottish Cup and National League Cup will be published on The Offside Line tomorrow.

Georgia v Scotland: mission accomplished in Tbilisi

Marr RFC1412115072252829160
Currie Chieftains14104046820026810252
Hawick RFC139313322051277146
Selkirk RFC1577133433135338
GHA RFC14590313440-1276329
Edinburgh ACC13472299338-395126
Glasgow Hawks144100291393-1025526
Biggar RFC16141163019543515073
Heriot's Blues15114055230324913158
Highland RFC16115051534017510155
Melrose Rugby161150366398-328052
Gala RFC15762400347537241
Cartha Queens15780487472159239
Stirling Wolves15771349354-56339
Watsonian FC15771349436-876137
Ayr RFC165101335462-1276230
Kelso RFC165110290503-2135328
Dundee HSFP162140251558-3072111

We hope you’ve enjoyed reading this article

Support our new, improved coverage this season 2019-20, with Super 6, National 1 and 2 leagues, fixtures and tables, and the small matter of our comprehensive coverage of Scotland at the RWC from Japan.

Invest in our gameyou can make a difference by keeping Scottish rugby at all levels in the news.

Alan Lorimer
About Alan Lorimer 143 Articles
Scotland rugby correspondent for The Times for six years and subsequently contributed to Sunday Times, Daily and Sunday Telegraph, Scotsman, Herald, Scotland on Sunday, Sunday Herald and Reuters. Worked in Radio for BBC. Alan is Scottish rugby journalism's leading voice when it comes to youth and schools rugby.