Glasgow v Edinburgh: Warriors recapture 1872 Cup

Danny Wilson's side bounced back from their heavy defeat to Benetton last time out with an energetic performance against capital rivals

Warriors full-back Cole Forbes celebrates scoring his team's opening try. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk
Warriors full-back Cole Forbes celebrates scoring his team's opening try. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk

Glasgow Warriors 29

Edinburgh 19

THE 1872 Cup has returned to Glasgow for the first time since 2017 after Warriors’ well-deserved victory over Edinburgh on an action-packed evening at Scotstoun.

There were seven tries in all, with four for the hosts securing a bonus point triumph, while both sides had a man sent-off. Mark Bennett and Oli Kebble were both shown first-half red cards for foul play.

Bennett was dismissed for a high tackle on Ali Price just after the half-hour mark, and Kebble struck out at Henry Pyrgos shortly before half-time, leaving referee Adam Jones little option.


Warren Gatland wanted to ‘send a message’ to Finn Russell about being a potential Test match starter

Eight Scots named in squad for Lions tour to South Africa

Win £1,000 of rugby kit with Macron Store Edinburgh (Colin Campbell Sports)


The visitors dominated the opening 10 minutes, but Glasgow took an early lead thanks to a Ross Thompson penalty. A couple of minutes later, they extended their advantage when Cole Forbes hit a superb line to go over untouched. Thompson converted for 10-0.

Glasgow were given an easy exit from the restart as Duhan van der Merwe was penalised, but the decision was reversed following handbags between the wing and Glasgow captain Fraser Brown. Edinburgh went to the corner and their maul allowed Dave Cherry to burrow over. Nathan Chamberlain converted.

The hosts hit back immediately as Brown atoned for his earlier error by winning a turnover, and Fotu Lokotui stretched out to score. Thompson converted again to restore the hosts’ 10-point cushion.

Glasgow were warned about their discipline so they had no grounds for complaint when Rob Harley was sent to the sin-bin after giving away another cheap penalty at a maul.

Edinburgh capitalised on their numerical superiority immediately with their maul again the source as Pierre Schoeman marked his 27th birthday with a try. Chamberlain converted Ince again to cut the gap to three points.

Scroll down to continue reading:


The Offside Line Season Appeal 2020 - 2021

Since our launch in 2016, The Offside Line has established itself as the leading independent, dedicated media outlet for Scottish rugby, averaging just over 250,000 page views per calendar month during 2020 – which is not bad going given that the game was in lockdown for five of those months!

We are passionate about rugby at all levels across the whole of Scotland (and beyond) and are committed to continue shining a light on our sport in order to maintain its profile during these uncertain times.

We also believe that it is more important than ever that we report on and analyse how the game is being run locally, nationally and globally, at a time when some major decisions on issues such as season-structure and finance will have a profound impact on rugby’s future.

If you value what we do and feel able to support us in our quest to continually grow the breadth and depth of Scottish rugby coverage, you can do this by making a one-off donation, or by supporting us with a monthly contribution.

Thank you for reading The Offside Line.


 

There was further drama when Bennett was shown red following a ‘captain’s challenge’ by Brown. The officials deemed that his shoulder had made contact with Price’s chin, and although there was clearly no intent there was only one sanction permissible by the letter of the law.

The hosts were then dealt a blow when Edinburgh used a ‘challenge’ to review a clash between Kebble and Pyrgos, which resulted in the Scotland’s prop’s elbow swinging into the side of the scrum-half’s head. Once again, red was the outcome.

Under the law variations which are being trialled during this Rainbow Cup campaign, that meant both players would not be allowed to return to the match but could be replaced after their respective sides had played the next 20 minutes with 14 men.

With the clock two minutes into the red, Glasgow scored a third try as Brown drove over. Edinburgh challenged the call, but Jones decided that Thomas Lambert had not obstructed Jamie Ritchie, and the try stood. Thompson converted to make it a 24-14 at the break.

 

Glasgow lost Scott Cummings – who took an accidental knee to the head from Bill Mata – within 30 seconds of the restart, but kept their composure and crossed for a fourth try seven minutes later.

From a free-kick at a five-metre scrum, Price went quickly before the ball was sent wide to Kyle Steyn, who marked his first Scotstoun appearance since February 2020 with a try to seal the bonus point.

The harum-scarum theme of the evening continued when Glasgow found themselves once again on the wrong end of a series of penalties, which led to Stuart McInally, just off the bench for his first appearance after four months out injured, sneaking over. Chamberlain couldn’t convert.

Edinburgh threw everything at their hosts in the final quarter, but were unable to find a way through a resolute Glasgow defensive effort, which persisted despite the loss of Richie Gray to a yellow card for collapsing a maul.

Even when McInally thought he had a second try, Ratu Tagive was on hand to hold up the former Scotland captain.

 

Teams –

Glasgow Warriors: C Forbes; R Tagive (T Lambert 39-59)), N Grigg, S McDowall, K Steyn (N Matawalu 65); R Thompson (P Horne 65), A Price; O Kebble, F Brown (G Turner 60), Z Fagerson (E Pieretto 71), R Harley, S Cummings (R Gray 41), F Lokotui, T Gordon (K McDonald 58), R Wilson.

Edinburgh: D Hoyland; E Sau, M Bennett (J Johnstone 53), G Taylor, D van der Merwe; N Chamberlain, H Pyrgos (C Shiel 63); P Schoeman, D Cherry (S McInally 46), W Nel, J Hodgson, G Gilchrist (M Sykes 60), J Ritchie (M Kunavula 40), L Crosbie, V Mata.

 

Scorers –

Glasgow Warriors: Tries: Forbes, Lokotui, Brown, Steyn; Cons: Thompson 3; Pen: Thompson.

Edinburgh: Tries: Cherry, Schoeman, McInally; Cons: Chamberlain 2.

Scoring sequence (Glasgow first): 3-0, 8-0, 10-0; 10-5, 10-7; 15-7, 17-7, 17-12, 17-14, 22-14, 24-14 (h-t) 29-14, 29-19

 

Yellow cards –

Glasgow Warriors: Harley (28mins), Gray (72mins)

 

Red cards –

Glasgow Warriors: Kebble (38mins)

Edinburgh: Bennett (33mins)


Win £1,000 of rugby kit with Macron Store Edinburgh (Colin Campbell Sports)

We hope you’ve enjoyed reading this article

Support our coverage  of all levels of Scottish rugby.

Invest in our gameyou can make a difference by keeping Scottish rugby at all levels in the news.

About Gavin Harper 7 Articles
Gavin is a freelance journalist and former Editor of SCRUM Magazine. After graduating from Edinburgh Napier University, during which time he won a Scottish Student Journalism Award for 'Best Sport Story', he began his career as a Senior news and sports reporter at the East Lothian Courier. After an 18-month spell as Editor of SCRUM Magazine, he now provides rugby content to a number of newspapers, magazines and websites. Twitter: @Gav_S_Harper

9 Comments

  1. I switched off with 10 minutes to go – bored by the stoppages.
    I blame the ref and the players, especially the Warriors who have a huge discipline problem.
    As for the red cards, an Oscar for Pyrgos. I’ve always been a fan, but no longer.
    Poor Mark Bennett. That red shows the shortcomings of the present rules.
    Next week can only be better…..hopefully????

    1
    3
  2. So Scottish rugby union is now the new football, shame on you Pyrgos, a shocking example for any youngster watching.

    6
    2
  3. And how long did the game last. Surely into the book of pub quiz questions you’ll never get asked as the latest ever 1872 cup finish.

  4. Edinburgh forwards do a reasonable shift but we have zero attack threat in the backs which should never be the case with strike runners like Sau and Duhan. I wonder if its time to freshen things up on the attack coach front. Well done Glasgow, they just wanted it more. Kebble’s elbow was definitely a red card. You just don’t get away with that nowadays but Pyrgos’s theatrical dive was a 2 out of 10 at best.

    15
  5. Glasgow desperately needed that win – a bit of pride restored. Steyn illustrated the enthusiasm of a man that has missed out on rugby for too long, while many of the others In fairness looking like players that need the summer break after playing too much rugby over a long and frustrating season. Thompson growing with every game. Cole Forbes looks promising too. Discipline has to improve all round.

    6
    1
  6. Glasgow desperately needed that win – a bit of pride restored. Steyn illustrated the enthusiasm of a man that has missed out on rugby for too long, while many of the others In fairness looking like players that need the summer break after playing too much rugby over a long and frustrating season. Thompson growing with every game. Cole Forbes looks promising too. Discipline has to improve all round.

    3
    1
  7. Good game, and a vital win for Glasgow. Certainly a better performance than the abysmal performance last week. For Glasgow thought Steyn was good after so long off, Forbes looked good in parts, and the forwards played with some grunt. For Edinburgh thought Hoyland had a good game, but they are still missing that cutting edge in attack particularly from the backs. I like the Red card experiment, I thought Bennett was unlucky , his poorly executed tackle like many of these reds nowadays, was compounded by the actions of others and as for Pyrgos ,his was straight play acting off the football pitch and shame on him for it.

    9
    1
  8. Barney – Methinks young Master Harper’s pro-Edinburgh bias is showing here.

    The Kebble red card was never a red in teh history of the game, and Henry Pyrgos should be ashamed of himself for his play-acting to get Oli sent off. No complaints about the Bennett red, mind you, in Marko’s defence, that was an ok tackle down Cumnock way.

    The referee was terrible, to both sides, but, Glasgow definitely appears to have a discipline problem.

    5
    9
    • Red cards have to be judged in the state of the game today rather than in the past if we are to prevent more players having problems caused by head injuries in later life.

      In addition players don’t get opponents sent-off. That’s what we have referees and TMOs for.

      4
      1

Comments are closed.