England v Scotland preview: will fortune favour Townsend’s brave selection calls?

Head coach has rolled the dice ahead of Calcutta Cup clash at Twickenham

Huw Jones has been given the nod ahead of defensive stalwart Chris Harris at outside-centre. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk
Huw Jones has been given the nod ahead of defensive stalwart Chris Harris at outside-centre. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk

FORTUNE favours the brave, or so one theory goes – but will Gregor Townsend’s decision to name Huw Jones in his Scotland starting XV for the first time since Italy in March 2021 prove a masterstroke or an exercise in rugby masochism? 

On his day, the Glasgow Warriors centre is an irresistible force who runs magnificent lines with pace and purpose to break open even the most miserly of defences, with his performance against England at Murrayfield in that 2018 victory a fond and enduring memory for all Scots who witnessed it.

With the zippy Ben White loading the bullets, and Townsend publicly encouraging Russell to showcase his full array of passing and kicking skills, the plan seems to be something close to all-out attack, to test an England team looking to find their feet under a new coach, having managed just one win in this fixture in the last five years and who have just four wins from their last 10 Six Nations games.

U20s Six Nations: heroic Scotland give England a fright

6N: After banishing Twickenham hoodoo, can Scotland make history with back-to-back wins?

6N: England v Scotland: Gregor Townsend explains some of his big selection calls

However, questions around Jones’ defence have pursued the now 29-year-old throughout his career, with his revolving door routine against England at Twickenham in 2017 and a couple of costly missed tackles which led directly to tries for Wales during the 2018 Six Nations among the most damning entries on the charge sheet.

Townsend’s desire for a more defensively robust squad ultimately led to Jones missing out on the 2019 World Cup in France – look how that turned out! – and this slight on Jones’ reputation has stuck, perhaps unfairly

“I don’t think I’ve ever been a bad defender,” said the man himself a few years ago. “I think there have been times obviously when I have missed tackles in games. It happens to everyone and some of mine have been in open field where there is an easy run to the try line. That obviously looks pretty bad but other ones have been system errors where I have been left out in the cold.”

After a season getting much-needed regular game-time in the English Premiership with Harlequins, Jones believes he has returned to Scotland a more rounded player, and the early evidence supports this, but he has managed just four appearances for Warriors since returning north last summer (due to a back injury and squad rotation) so this selection is a roll of the dice.

Three of those four games have been at 12 with Sione Tuipulotu at 13. The ‘Huwipulotu’ combination has been switched around for this step-up from club to international level, although the midfield pairing is, of course, interchangeable.

England under Steve Borthwick – six and a half weeks into the job – will play a simplified brand of rugby after the muddled thinking of the end of the Eddie Jones era. Attack coach Nick Evans’ mantra is ‘LQB’ – lightning quick ball – and the selection of twin playmakers in Marcus Smith at 10 and Owen Farrell at 12 will test Jones and Tuipulotu’s reading of the game and their ability to think on their feet.

Of course, if it all goes wrong, then defensive bulwark Chris Harris is waiting in the wings – which makes sense, so long as the horse has not already bolted by the time the Gloucester man trots off the bench.

With Jack van Poortvliet – a Leicester Tiger under Borthwick – at scrum-half, and an imposing back three built physically and psychologically to chase high-balls (full-back Freddy Steward is 6ft 5ins, Ollie Hassell-Collins making his debut on the left wing if 6ft 4ins and the elfin Max Malins on the right wing is a mere 5ft 11ins) , we can safely say that an aerial bombardment will be part of England’s battleplan today.

Townsend must have been tempted to pick the old warhorse Sean Maitland, who is his best available winger in the air. He’s gone for Kyle Steyn, who is solid in this area and in fine form for Glasgow, instead. Meanwhile, Duhan van der Merwe is big and enthusiastic and a handful chasing kicks, but isn’t anywhere near as commanding when on the receiving end.

Another priority for England under Borthwick will be sorting out a scrum which had lost its way, to turn it once again into an attacking weapon. Former Edinburgh boss Richard Cockerill, as the only coaching survivor from the Jones era (he is expected to move on, reportedly to Montpellier, after the tournament), is overseeing that task, and was typically blunt on the subject during Friday’s eve-of-match press conference.

“Certainly, from my point of view, our set-piece has to be a lot better,” he said. “Our scrum hasn’t been good enough and that’s something we need to improve, both in terms of the relationships with the referee and how we actually go about our business. We know that’s going to be a big test tomorrow because Pierre Schoeman, George Turner and WP Nel are a quality front-row. Our set-piece parts have to be a lot better if we’re going to compete at this level and win games at this level.”

When asked if Nel – the 36-year-old wearing No 3 because Zander Fagerson hasn’t recovered in time from a hamstring tear at the start of December – is the weak link, Cockerill retorted: “No, not at all. I’d probably class him in the same category as Dan Cole [the veteran Leicester tight-head who has been recalled to sit on the bench this afternoon]  around his set-piece ability. We know that’s going to be a fierce part of the game and WP is a quality scrummager. We treat him with a huge amount of respect.”

The reality is that Nel is not the force he once was, either in the tight or around the park. He’s honest, and brave, and will never let Scotland down, but lacks punch and mobility. Simon Berghan is undercooked in terms of game-time with Glasgow, where he ended up because Cockerill really didn’t fancy him at Edinburgh, but the big New Zealander proved on his first cap off the bench away to France in tricky circumstances back in 2017 that when switched on he can hold his own at the highest level – although you would have hoped he’d have kicked on a bit more by now.

Townsend has opted for an all-Glasgow replacement front-row with the logic being that this familiarity can help negate England’s power in the final quarter.

It’s a big day for Luke Crosbie at openside flanker. Tough as old boots, he will relish the opportunity to lay down a marker – such as he did when knocking England hooker Jamie George onto his backside and out of the game when Edinburgh got the better of Saracens at the DAM Health Stadium a fortnight ago.

Another emphatic declaration of intent from the East Lothian man would be handy to get the ball rolling this afternoon.

Today’s teams (kick-off 4.45pm):

England: F Steward; M Malins, J Marchant, O Farrell©, O Hassell-Collins; M Smith, J van Poortvliet; E Genge, J George, K Sinckler, M Itoje, O Chessum, L Ludlam, B Curry, A Dombrandt. Replacements: J Walker, M Vunipola, D Cole, N Isiekwe, B Earl, B Youngs, O Lawrence, A Watson.

Scotland: S Hogg; K Steyn, H Jones, S Tuipulotu, D van der Merwe; F Russell, B White; P Schoeman, G Turner, W Nel, R Gray, G Gilchrist, J Ritchie©, L Crosbie, M Fagerson. Replacements: F Brown, J Bhatti, S Berghan, J Gray, J Dempsey, G Horne, B Kinghorn, C Harris.

Six Nations preview: superpowers, fatal flaws and some bold predictions

About David Barnes 3911 Articles
David has worked as a freelance rugby journalist since 2004 covering every level of the game in Scotland for publications including he Herald/Sunday Herald, The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The Scotsman/Scotland on Sunday/Evening News, The Daily Record, The Daily Mail/Mail on Sunday and The Sun.


  1. Centre were excellent defensively and even better with the ball. Lightyears ahead of recent combos. Steyn is much quicker than in previous seasons and was superb as was Duhan. Happyer seeing Gray compete on opposition line outs too. If we eliminate errors and can be a touch more physical we have a platform to work with here.

  2. It’s such a Scottish thing to concentrate on someone supposed weaknesses rather than extenuate their definite strength. What is not mentioned above is Jones’s magnificent attacking displays……vs Ireland England and Wales, his part in ‘the pass’ v England.

    • Yes, it is, and maybe the shackles that stopped us winning a game or two.

      All I know is we have the best squad in 20+ years capable of pulling off any result in the 6N. The individuals are remarkable players and paid professionals. I think the fine margins maybe have a hint of individual flair, the major component is really the team clicking as a whole.

  3. Toonie’s best selection for a long time. Main weakness is at tight head.
    If Zander Fagerson and been fit to start with Nel as back up this would have been brilliant .
    Nel is a legend but is unlikely to last the pace. Berghan has really struggled for Glasgow in recent weeks so I am not hopeful if he needs to play more than 20 minutes.
    Fingers crossed Nel doesn’t pick up an early injury.

  4. Last time I watched them for Glasgow, Jones and Tuipolotu played interchangeably 12/13. Given that outside centre is the hardest place to defend, I am interested how they will line up in attack and defence today.

  5. Whether fortune favours his calls or not, they are for once – at least for the most part – what I would like to have seen. Townsend realises he would have been be run out of town for not picking Finn; the two Glasgow centres are in devastating form; Richie Gray has five inches on Itoje and will make life extremely difficult for him at the line; and Crosbie gets his totally deserved chance in place of a not-yet match fit Mish. Not quite perfect though and the sooner Dobie gets involved in a Scotland match-day 23 the better for himself, his club and his country. Maitland might also have done a job for us and is in fine form, although Steyn is a tank out wide and will give his all, even if he lacks the required pace at international level. I would have picked Healey ahead of Kinghorn, who I assume is covering 10 and 15 but frankly I would not be happy seeing him in either. Had assumed the point of him being shifted to the wing for Edinburgh was that Toony saw his pet project playing there, but the other selections for today suggest otherwise. Good luck to all the lads – your chance for glory and nothing to lose in going for three in a row and back to backs at Twickenham. Gie em laldie!

  6. FWIW, I think Jones has looked solid defensively this term. I was feeling a bit flat about our prospects a week ago, but I am now thinking that this side is pretty much the best available and we’re going to give it a go. Starting to get quite excited about the match.

  7. An article of complete negativity from a Scottish perspective. Reading this you would think we are completely fragile over the park and England are a powerhouse and a shoe in. I’m normally balanced on the half glass empty side but even I would consider our chances today are at worst evens. England have one outstanding player in their team at second row the rest range from good internationals to unproven at test level. I honestly believe this will be a relatively comfortable win for Scotland.

Comments are closed.