Edinburgh v Bulls: hosts ride their luck and weather a storm to pick up valuable win

Mike Blair's side survive a late scare at rain-lashed DAM Health Stadium

Edinburgh's Magnus Bradbury and Bulls' Marcell Coetzee compete for the ball at a line-out on a rain-lashed evening at the DAM Health Stadium. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk
Edinburgh's Magnus Bradbury and Bulls' Marcell Coetzee compete for the ball at a line-out on a rain-lashed evening at the DAM Health Stadium. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk

Edinburgh 17

Vodacom Bulls 10

DAVID BARNES @ The DAM Health Stadium

IT wasn’t particularly pretty and there was a decent dollop of good fortunate involved at the end, but Edinburgh just about deserved the four points they took from this gritty tussle at the rain-lashed DAM Health Stadium.

Having twice let winning positions slip through their fingers during the last fortnight – losing to an injury-time drop-goal a fortnight ago away to Benetton and then having to make do with a frustrating draw at home to the Stormers last weekend – Edinburgh head coach Mike Blair declared himself delighted with the way his side held on this time to get a valuable home win.

“We’ve talked a fair bit about how we manage the end of the game and still didn’t get it quite right,” he said. “But what I said to the guys was that I hate watching games in the rain, I think they are a poor spectacle, but I loved that game.”


Zebre v Glasgow: weary Warriors keep up winning run

Premiership: depleted Selkirk undone by Edinburgh Accies

Super6: Heriot’s humbled by Barreto-inspired Boroughmuir Bears


“I loved the heart that we showed and the will to put the effort in for the jersey. We ended up with players out of position all over the place, with two forwards defending in the backs, and found a way to get a result so I am delighted with that.”

When Bulls winger Madosh Tambwe swept past Damien Hoyland and rode a Darcy Graham tackle on his way to touching down in the corner with only five minutes to go, there appeared to be a distinct possibility that another hard luck story was on the cards. The conversion to square it would have been from the touchline, but if there is one player in world rugby you would back to come up with the goods in that situation then it is Morne Steyn, the Bulls’ veteran stand-off who nervelessly kicked the winning points when the Springboks secured a series success over the Lions during the summer. Fortunately for Edinburgh, referee Ben Whitehouse opted to review the try on the big screen and reached the conclusion that there had been a double movement.

So, Edinburgh held on for a dramatic win, which leaves them sixth in the United Rugby Championship table, behind fifth placed Ospreys on points difference, with a trip to Italy to take on winless Zebre on the agenda next week before the league pauses for the Autumn international window.

“I think it was a fairly clear and obvious double movement,” was Blair’s take on the disallowed try, delivered with a knowing twinkle in his eye.

“You need to get these decisions sometimes,” he added. “Against Benetton two weeks ago we didn’t get any decisions in the last five minutes, and against the Stormers they got the benefit of the doubt three or four times, so these things happen. Let’s reflect on the big strides we’ve made to see out that game.”

The first five minutes were scrappy, then Edinburgh suddenly clicked into gear with a half dozen slick phases which took play from the left to the right touchline and then back again, before Hoyland’s toe-poke into the in-goal area set-up the try for full-back Henry Immelman.

The game then slumped back into its pre-try routine, with both sides struggling to engineer the fast ball needed to get the game-breakers like Edinburgh’s Graham and his opposite number Kurt-Lee Arendse into a position where they could make an impact.

Edinburgh’s line-out was creaking as well, which meant they struggled to build any meaningful pressure, and great work by Bismarck du Plessis over the tackled Stuart McInally earned a penalty which Bulls stand-off Chris Smith sent home to narrow the gap to two points.

The game did burst into life again just before the half hour mark when home skipper Grant Gilchrist charged-down Embrose Papier and the Bulls had to scramble to rescue the situation behind their own line, but they managed to hold on and eventually found an exit route with a Smith cross-field kick to Arendse on the left touchline, who scuttled to safety past a despairing Graham tackle.

Bulls then shot themselves in the foot with three fairly soft penalties – for an offside, a side-entry by loose-head prop Lizo Gooboka and a petulant shove by du Plessis on Pierre Schoeman – which Jaco van der Walt took full advantage of to make it 14-3 at the break.

There was, however, a setback for the hosts when van der Walt picked up a serious looking shoulder injury whilst making a tackle during the last play of the first half. “He is struggling a bit so we will have to see the extent of it, but it didn’t look good on first viewing,” said Blair.

 

Season Appeal 2022

We hope you are enjoying our unrivalled coverage of Scottish Rugby. While mainstream media continues to reduce its interest in the rugby family in Scotland, The Offside Line does its very best to make sure all levels of the domestic game are reported.

Our commitment to the game and sharing its stories means that we do not have a paywall, so we would ask you (only if you can!) to support The Offside Line, either with a one off donation, or with a monthly contribution.

We have been keeping Scottish rugby in the news since 2016 and will have 3 million page views this year, making The Offside Line first for Scottish rugby.

 

James Lang, who played stand-off earlier in his career, moved into the No10 slot and Edinburgh initially adapted fairly seamlessly, with a searching kick by Mark Bennett then a scything break by James Johnstone putting Bulls under pressure early in the second half.

But they missed an opportunity to stretch their lead when Lang hit the post following a scrum penalty awarded to Edinburgh just after WP Nel had come on at tight-head prop

Then, with 10 minutes to go, Bulls found a way into Edinburgh territory, and after a series of close-range drives, visiting captain Marcell Coetzee muscled in for the try.

Steyn’s conversion made it 17-14, which was just a bit too close for comfort for the hosts, but they showed good composure to get back in the strike zone then earn a ruck penalty. With Lang now off injured, Bennett stepped forward to take the shot at goal, and he made no mistake.

But there was still eight minutes to go and time for that late drama via Tambwe’s interjection, but Edinburgh got away with it.

 

Teams –

Edinburgh: H Immelman; D Graham, M Bennett, J Lang, D Hoyland; J van der Walt ((B Vellacott 71), C Shiel; P Schoeman (B Venter 77), S McInally (D Cherry 61), L De Bruin (W Nel 50), M Sykes (P Phillips 50), G Gilchrist, M Bradbury, L Crosbie (C Boyle 73), V Mata (M Kunavula 66).

Bulls: D Kriel (L Mapoe. 66); M Tambwe, C Hendricks, H Vorster. K Arendse; C Smith (M Steyn 57), M Papier (W Steenkamp 52); L Gooboka (S Matanzima 58), B Du Plessis (S Erasmus 66), M Smith (R Hunt 40), J Swanepoel (W Steenkamp 52), R Nortje, M Coetzee, A Botha, M Uys (E Louw 40).

Referee: B Whitehouse

 

Scorers –

Edinburgh: Tries: Immelman; Pen; Van der Walt 3, Bennett.

Bulls: Try: Coetzee; Con: Steyn; Pen: Smith.

Scoring sequence (Edinburgh first): 5-0; 5-3; 8-3; 11-3; 14-3 (h-t) 14-8; 14-10; 17-10


Zebre v Glasgow: weary Warriors keep up winning run

About David Barnes 2756 Articles
David has worked as a freelance rugby journalist since 2004 covering every level of the game in Scotland for publications including he Herald/Sunday Herald, The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The Scotsman/Scotland on Sunday/Evening News, The Daily Record, The Daily Mail/Mail on Sunday and The Sun.

9 Comments

  1. It could have been a much more comfortable win if they hadn’t squandered some great position by losing lineouts, (which improved when Cherry came on). Having said that, they matched the Bulls very well with physicality and had dominance in the scrum. The mounting injuries are concerning.

    • Perhaps a tad unfair, Marshall Sykes (who, had otherwise a really fine game) doesn’t quite get up as well in the lineouts as Philips so Cherry did have another option. I’d also point out that McInally (and Sykes for that matter) was excellent around the park all day.

      • Yes, Bulls seemed often to throw a front jumper up high which made it difficult to get over the first jumpers and not end up overthrowing – a bit like Glasgow use Ritchie Gray.
        It was a difficult evening on the touch line.

  2. good win to tough out.

    Bradbury good, he has always had the talent, but yes he has been pushed back down the pecking order for a club and country due to lack of consistency and work rate. This was one game. If he can repeat it every week, he moves up the pecking order – but he is competing with a lot of good back rows just for Edinburgh.

    Sheil was also excellent, not doing the flashy stuff he is known for and Vellacott has been doing, but a lot of good mature game management, better than Vellacott has been in that respect. But again, one game. Repeat it and he moves up the pecking order to a starter not a bench option

  3. It’s never straightforward and it’s always tight but I thought Edinburgh played really well last night. Bismark and Coetzee will always win ball at the breakdown, I thought we showed plenty of steel. If we’d converted Johnston’s break then it could have been a bit more comfortable. On the try at the end, I thought it was a score on first viewing but he was tackled around the 5m line and there’s was plenty of movement after so it was the right call. Pleasure to see Morne Steyn and he definitely would have kicked the conversion.

  4. A slightly unkind report. It was a tight encounter with Edinburgh having to do some stout defending in a second half plagued by i
    The double movement was fairly obvious from where I was in that corner as the winger was caught and downed by Graham. Lang’s pen miss was a bit embarrassing from pretty much right in front.

    And you could have been unlucky enough to watch the Glasgow game earlier, wow that was depressing for both sides to review. There will be a lot of sore bodies on Monday, Edinburgh will have to regroup quickly, assess who Gregor will allow to play and go to Italy with a steely eye.

  5. A slightly unkind report. It was a tight encounter with Edinburgh having to do some stout defending in a second half plagued by incessant rain making handling difficult. The double movement was fairly obvious from where I was in that corner when the winger was caught and downed by Graham. Lang’s pen miss was a bit embarrassing from pretty much right in front.
    The fighting rearguard, in the face of some very physical offence, was top drawer with the ‘sixteenth man’ in the stands finally making their presence felt after years in the empty Murrayfield bowl.

    Great drama and guts and those that stayed away should really regret not being there.

    And you could always have been unlucky enough to watch the Glasgow game earlier. Wow, that’ll be depressing for both sides to review – but a win is a win, so good for the Warriors.
    There will be a lot of sore bodies on Monday, Edinburgh will have to regroup quickly, assess who Gregor will allow to play and go to Italy with the same steely eye.

    3
    1
  6. So, a couple of rucks before Coetzee’s try, did anyone else see the guy flying into the ruck from the side, looked to be right in front of Whitehouse ..???

    • Saw it plain as day from the stands! Touch judges were ignoring constant Bulls offside all night as well. Something that’s being overlooked in all the ballyhoo about the double movement is what a fantastic tackle from Darcy it was. That lad is some player!

      9
      1

Comments are closed.