Create your free account on The Offside Line
Get instant access to Scottish rugby news and enjoy 2 free articles every month. Stay close to the game — sign up in seconds.
Already have an account? Sign in

IAIN HAY @Scotstoun
EDINBURGH extinguished Glasgow’s hopes of a play-off berth with a try in added-time to finish Scottish interest in the Celtic Challenge.
It started in madcap, thrilling, somewhat error-strewn fashion, and so it it continued. Eilidh McGilviray knocked on the kick-off to give Edinburgh the put-in at the scrum.
They made a hash of it though, the ball from Emily Love squirting through Nicole Marlow’s legs, eventually leading to Briar McNamara intercepting possession and hurtling into Edinburgh’s 22. She offloaded to captain Holland Bogan but she was hauled down 10m short of the line. Edinburgh defended resolutely until Ceitidh Ainsworth threw her own intercepted pass.

Edinburgh’s summer signing came off the bench for England Under-20s when they suffered a humbling defeat which wrecked their Grand Slam hopes at Myreisde in February 2018

Former Northampton Saints and Mitsubishi Sagamihara Dynaboars stand-off ready to put past experiences into practice in the Scottish capital

47-year-old is unveiled in new role just eight days after stepping down from Scotland job on compassionate grounds
Edinburgh started to get a grip on proceedings, and although coughing up a line-out on the edge of the Glasgow 22, they dominated the other set-piece throughout to give them easy territory.
Hannah Ramsay made the first of many breaks before an Edinburgh knock-on, only for them to win the penalty against the head. They went to touch, only for that to go wrong again.
However, when Glasgow cleared, what also happened again was Ramsay carving through their defence. They quickly shipped the ball left where captain Hannah Walker slid in despite the best efforts of Claudia McLaren to push her into touch.
From the restart, Edinburgh nearly doubled their advantage. After receiving, Marlow’s hanging kick took a fortuitous – if you’re an Edinburgh fan – bounced into Adelle Ferrie’s hands, it was swiftly moved wide and Cieron Bell went haring down the right flank. McNamara didn’t give up the chase though, and forced Bell to knock into touch just two-metres from the Glasgow line. McNamara then picked herself up, dusted the rubber crumbs off herself and hammered the ball clear after Glasgow had tidied up a messy line-out.
The pressure was all coming one way though and usually through Ramsay’s hands. Her offload put Catriona Moody through a hole and into the 22. They finished in similar fashion to the first, only difference being Bethan Mathieson being the one to touch down.
Although Edinburgh’s line-out was malfunctioning, Glasgow’s was hardly any better, referee Sam O’Neil’s whistle for a forward pass stopping a breakaway after they had thrown too long.
The exceptional Alex Stewart then had a barrel through the middle after more tidy midfield offloading, but she herself knocked on a few phases later. She had another go, showing some nifty footwork too, as the half was drawing to a close but teammate Aila Ronald was penalised for sealing off on the Glasgow line.
Having seen the scrum be pummelled, Glasgow brought on Aicha Sutcliffe and Imogen Spence at half-time, along with Millie Warren, and they seemingly made an instant impact, at least in open field.
There was more breakdown chaos, but this time it was Glasgow who profited when Sophie Murphy came up with the ball, saw a gap and ran home for a score that had looked beyond Glasgow. Replacement Warren knocked over the extras from right in front of the sticks. Despite Glasgow’s front-row change-up, the referee’s arm was still going in Edinburgh’s direction at scrum time and, vitally, Edinburgh’s touch-finders were more accurate.
A McNamara penalty had failed to find touch, bounced off the hard synthetic surface and went dead. Scrum Edinburgh. Penalty Edinburgh. Territory. Now in Glasgow’s 22, they forced another penalty, five metres out from the posts. They went for the scrum, Glasgow probably expected the shove to come on but Moody came bursting out from the base and powered over.
When Glasgow did eventually find touch and they managed to finish a line-out, the dummy round of Sutcliffe allowed McNamara to put Warren through, who converted her own try. An early tackle on Spence gave Glasgow a penalty centre-field on the Edinburgh 10m line. Warren stepped up and slammed it over. Somehow, Glasgow were level in a must-win game with 72 minutes.
A high shot from earlier try-scorer Murphy seemed to give Edinburgh one last chance to put the ball deep into Glasgow territory, which they did. Bogan got up and seemed to steal it, but the ball came back on Edinburgh’s side. They got up to the Glasgow try-line, and over the Glasgow try-line. But were held up. Relief for Glasgow.
For now. McNamara’s clearance was of reasonable length, but Lisa Brown’s running it back was nearly as long. Edinburgh were deep in the 22 and they did not fail this time. Clock in the red, replacement Kaylee Fraser won the match, and inter-city bragging rights. Which, on balance over the 80, they deserved.
Teams –
Glasgow Warriors: P Mellanby; C McLaren, N Flynn, B McNamara, S Phimister; C Ainsworth, R Darroch; P Fletcher, M Hyland, K Lindsay; H Bogan ©, S Murphy; G Thomson, E McGilviray, E Coubrough Subs: A Sutcliffe, F Gracie, I Spence, F Walker, S Main, M Warren, H Smyth, R Gibson.
Edinburgh Rugby: B Mathieson; C Bell, R Philipps, H Ramsay, H Walker (c); N Marlow, E Love; A Wilson, A Ronald, M Poolman; A Ferrie, N Logan, L McGrotty, A Stewart, C Moody Subs: K Fraser, T Tawake, F Sutherland, N Howat, C Russell, P Benson, L Brown, S Haddow.
Referee: Sam O’Neil
Scorers –
Glasgow: Tries: Murphy, Warren; Cons: Warren 2; Pens: Warren
Edinburgh: Tries: Walker, Mathieson, Moody, Fraser.
Scoring sequence (Glasgow first): 0-5; 0-10 (h-t) 5-10; 7-10; 7-15; 7-17; 12-17; 14-17, 17-17, 17-22
Player of the Match: Had Glasgow pinched it then Millie Warren would have claimed the gong for going ‘Full D-Mac’, however, the player whose name was first jotted down as a contender wins it. Hannah Ramsay beat defenders and made telling breaks, got the offloads in, defended solidly and even kicked some touch-finders. Excellent all-round performance.
Talking Point: Edinburgh really had the better of the important facets of the game. Kicking battle was won comfortably, with the exception of off the tee, and although the line-out was wobbly, the scrum was dominant. Solid foundations from which to build on.

Former Northampton Saints and Mitsubishi Sagamihara Dynaboars stand-off ready to put past experiences into practice in the Scottish capital

Former Scotland scrum-half replaces Claire Cruickshank ahead of this coming season’s Celtic Challenge which will kick-off in December

James Grayson was a key recruit this summer but new attack coach believes Ross Thompson and Cammy Scott will make sure selection is not a foregone conclusion

New assistant coach is impressed with skill-level across the squad but says the capital need to be ruthless when they get in the stroke zone

“When we got engaged and we locked the date in, I was still contracted at Mitsubishi in Japan and I didn't necessarily see myself 100...

During her playing days as a scrum-half, Dalgliesh represented Scotland at the 2006 and 2010 Women’s Rugby World Cups, and has since...

It is going to be fascinating to see how (or indeed if) it all comes together during the coming months ahead, although Tim Sampson – the...

"I think coming in as a new coach, my job is to get an understanding of what makes these guys tick and how they want to play as well,"...

Another new name to feature in this year’s intake is Callum Reidy. Another Scottish-qualified prospect, the Australian-born scrum-half...

“There's some unbelievable talent within the group,” the Australian said earlier today (Tuesday) in his first press conference since...

Fergusson has also worked with the GB women’s sevens team and previously served as director of rugby at Ayr and the Ayrshire Bulls where...

Hodge was initially recruited by the IRFU by fellow Australian David Nucifora, who was that organisation’s performance directory at the...

Edinburgh’s summer signing came off the bench for England Under-20s when they suffered a humbling defeat which wrecked their Grand Slam hopes at Myreisde in February 2018

Former Northampton Saints and Mitsubishi Sagamihara Dynaboars stand-off ready to put past experiences into practice in the Scottish capital

47-year-old is unveiled in new role just eight days after stepping down from Scotland job on compassionate grounds
Iain, an accurate report of how the game unfolded. The question I must ask of the Edinburgh Coaches and players is ‘Why did it have to come to the final game before the team showed real backbone?’ Scrummaging was superb, rucking was vastly improved and tackling was the best I have seen all season. Looking at the negatives, we still have problems with lines out, passing and catching, ball retention in the tackle. I have concerns about the speed and accuracy of pass from the base of scrums and rucks. However, last night, there was a determination about the Edinburgh team that was sadly lacking the rest of the season and they thoroughly deserved the win. As for Glasgow last night their usual key players and ball carriers were outplayed.