Aberdeen merger talks breakdown: An opportunity lost

Aberdeen Grammar hosted league champions Ayr in round three of the BT Cup back in January, but big matches like this are going to remain rare occasions in the north-east until decisive action is taken. Image courtesy: Howard Moles

by JACK NIXON

NEWS that talks aimed to bring about a merger of the north-east’s top two clubs have been called off after weeks of discussions can only be regarded, in my opinion, as sad news, and more crucially an opportunity lost.

When senior officials from Aberdeen Grammar and Aberdeenshire sat down in late April to have merger talks, my heart soared, seeing the initiative as one that would address, even arrest, the decline of top tier rugby in the area.

It is, after all, not that long ago that Aberdeen Grammar were not only in the Premiership, but pushing to be the best club side in Scotland, only to falter in the run-in Since then they have struggled to even maintain a place in National League One, having narrowly avoided relegation in the last two seasons.

Aberdeenshire on the other hand have been making a brave fist of gaining promotion of late from National League Two, making a merger to pool resources a sound platform on which to build a structure for the future.

The players from both clubs certainly seem to agree, including last season’s two captains.

”When I heard that talks were likely to bring about a merger I was excited about the idea of having a pyramid system in Aberdeen. Pooling the combined playing resources makes good sense, leading hopefully to the north-east having a top club,” said Calum Champion, the Grammar skipper.

”The aim of having a combined side has great appeal. Bringing back Premiership rugby to the city has to be a priority. It would be particularly good to have competition for places, something I believe both sets of players could live with. As it stands, rugby in the Caledonia  region is not in a good place, even although there are some talented players around. I just hope the talks can resume again,” said Greig Ryan of Aberdeenshire.

The official line from the two clubs was provided in a joint press release, acknowledging that discussions had been held and encouragingly concluding that: ”Productive lines of communication between the clubs shall remain open to facilitate the best result for rugby in the Aberdeen area.”

I shall optimistically cling to that expressed sentiment, hoping that once the dust has settled and some bruised egos have been massaged, it will be possible for Gordon Thomson, chairman of Aberdeen Grammar, and Alasdair Farquharson, president of Aberdeenshire, both good men, to sit down again in the interests of rugby in Scotland’s third biggest city, and plot a way to success in keeping with the fine traditions of the north-east game.

In the meantime, the so called lesser lights of the local game look on, knowing in their heart of hearts that a merger of the Rubislaw and Woodside clubs would have positive benefits for them, not least giving aspiring players the target of playing at the highest level in the club set-up without having to pack their bags and head south; whilst also bringing back some status to a city which has been dealt some hefty blows by the economic downturn in the oil industry.

After 20 years of reporting on the north-east game, I remain hopeful that there will be a change of hearts and minds. After all, similar initiatives are taking place all over Scotland, including down the road at Dundee.

We hope you’ve enjoyed reading this article

Support our new, improved coverage this season 2019-20, with Super 6, National 1 and 2 leagues, fixtures and tables, and the small matter of our comprehensive coverage of Scotland at the RWC from Japan.

Invest in our gameyou can make a difference by keeping Scottish rugby at all levels in the news.

Jack Nixon
About Jack Nixon 29 Articles
Jack is a Borderer, born in Langholm, and a graduate of Moray House College of Education in Edinburgh. He was a founder member of Livingston Rugby Club in 1968 and has been rugby correspondent for the Aberdeen Press and Journal since 1997. He has been going to Murrayfield man and boy since 1954!

1 Comment

  1. Having travelled all the way to Aberdeen from Ayr several years ago, when “Grammar” were more of a force to be reckoned with, I was surprised at the poor local turnout which seemed to barely outnumber Ayr’s travelling support.
    Pooling resources & support makes common sense both from the playing point & from the point of revenue generation through sponsorship & potential bar takings.
    Aberdeen is big enough to support a team capable of competing in premiership. A relaunch of a new composite club could well create the impetus necessary to render that dream a realistic target.

Comments are closed.