1872 Cup analysis: new national defence coach Steve Tandy has his work cut out

An entertaining contest but neither team had to work particularly hard for the seven tries they shared at Murrayfield

Huw Jones on his way to scoring Glasgow Warriors' fist try. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk
Huw Jones on his way to scoring Glasgow Warriors' first try. Image: © Craig Watson - www.craigwatson.co.uk

I DON’T know who coined the phrase ‘defence wins matches’ but it has probably been around since William Webb Ellis said a metaphorical ‘sod it’  to himself all those years ago and broke with convention by picking up the ball and running with it.

Certainly, it is one of rugby’s unwritten rules that seems to have survived the game’s transition from an amateur to a professional sport and, if the mantra remains relevant, don’t stick your mortgage on Scotland for the Six Nations.

The second 1872 derby game was a free-scoring affair with the two teams sharing a total of seven tries in all, four of which went to the home side. This made for a fascinating and hugely entertaining match but what it says about the Scottish rugby mindset is a little worrying.

1872 Cup: Darcy Graham claims double as Edinburgh sink Glasgow Warriors

1872 Cup: Richard Cockerill rejoices in Edinburgh’s ‘huge character’

Former SRU stalwart Fred McLeod passes away

Glasgow’s opening score on 24 minutes by a rejuvenated Huw Jones was an exception to the rule as Edinburgh’s defence held firm for several minutes while Glasgow probed until the visitors eventually manufactured a two-on-one in acres of space on the right flank. Duhan van der Merwe was caught in two minds and ended up marking no one, rather than jamming in on eventual scorer Jones which would, at least, have made Ruaridh Jackson’s final pass that much more difficult.

But after the break it appeared that all either side needed to do to score a try was hold onto possession for a few phases inside the opposition red zone and the defence would wave the white flag and escort some attacker to the try line.

The five second half tries came in just 26 minutes, so at a rate of almost one every five minutes, and the only player who was forced to break sweat was Darcy Graham who had to find his top gear up the right flank of the field for that last hurrah two minutes from time.

What was it that Shaun Edwards used to say at Wasps and, more recently, at Wales? “You get into the defensive line and, if you’ve broken your leg, then you hop into the line.” Sadly, that sort of Alamo attitude seems entirely alien to Scotland’s players who either lack the technique, the conditioning or the mental resilience to defend for multiple phases on or near their own goal line.

Scott Cummings scored his 52 minute try following a good break from Adam Hastings, after just six phases of play following an attacking line-out; finding a hole beside the breakdown that should have been filled by Grant Gilchrist. Equally guilty was prop Pierre Schoeman who somehow won the man-of-the-match award despite tackling the wrong man altogether, a penalty offence in itself.

George Horne’s try was even easier because Graham was caught manning the piller/post position at the very side of the breakdown. The little Glasgow scrummy brushed aside the winger’s challenge thanks to a couple of big forwards who propelled him over the line.

It was shooting fish and scoring was even easier at the other end of the field.

Henry Pyrgos probably should have started this match but even he wouldn’t claim that he had to work terribly hard for his 61 minute try. Bill Mata picked and drove off a scrum to get behind Glasgow’s defence, sucking in so many defenders that Pyrgos had an open run to the line. Obviously Mata is a handful on the charge but one phase from set-piece was all it took to put a Pyrgos-sized dent in Glasgow’s defence.

And things could have been a lot worse had referee Mike Adamson policed the offside line strictly. Instead the referee turned a Nelsonian blind eye to repeated infringements which infuriated Richard Cockerill in the coaches’ box, “OFFSIDE!….OFFSIDE!”, and enabled both defences to stay on top for much of the first half.

Scotland have just hired a new defence coach and, if Steve Tandy was watching, it must have been with a sinking feeling because the Welshman has to change Scotland’s collective mindset in little over a month. And by a month I mean the one week he will have with the whole Scotland squad before the Six Nations. And by one week I mean whatever time he can beg off Gregor Townsend in those seven short days.

At the end of the 1872 derby at Murrayfield, I made my way home and watched another derby on TV, this one between Munster and Leinster at a raucous Thomond Park. It ended with just one try throughout the entire 80 minutes that went to Leinster. Both teams displayed John Wayne levels of true, defensive grit but the visitors’ resilience in keeping Munster tryless at Thomond as the home side threw everything at the thin blue line, in multiple phase play that was well into the twenties, was in stark contrast to the welcome mat laid out by Scotland’s pro-teams.

Many of those same Irishmen will play many of the players on show at Murrayfield when Ireland host Scotland on the opening weekend of the Six Nations. We will likely discover if defence still wins matches.

Scotland’s best uncapped team? Barry Stewart’s selection

About Iain Morrison 151 Articles
Iain was capped 15 times for Scotland at openside flanker between his debut against Ireland during the 1993 Six Nations and his final match against New Zealand at the 1995 World Cup in South Africa. He was twice a Cambridge ‘Blue’ and played his entire club career with London Scottish (being inducted into the club’s Hall of Fame in 2016). Iain is a lifelong member of Linlithgow Rugby Club. After hanging up his boots, he became rugby correspondent for The Sunday Herald, before moving to The Scotland on Sunday for 16 years, and he has also guest written for various other publications.


  1. In the same way Irish teams (in particular) will go 10,15,20 phases in attack sticking to their process, their defence is organised and committed also for multi phases. We dont have multi phase discipline and grit in attack or defence sadly.

  2. I always enjoy reading Iain’s articles, which, coming from a former international, have insight some other journalists perhaps do not have. The concerns over our defence at national level are valid, we only have to look at tries conceded per game when Taylor was defence coach to see it has been an issue for some time. My hope is Tandy, along with De Villiers, will bring a hard edge and, dare i say it, nastiness to our game that has been missing for some time. As a positive, it’s fantastic to see how well our centres are playing: Jones, now he is getting game-time, is showing his quality and is surely back in Townsend’s thoughts. Personally, I don’t buy that Johnson should be the ‘shoe-in’ centre he is being described as and I feel he often flatters to deceive…

  3. Iain’s been a bit kind about the Huw Jones try here. Kinghorn initially did well to help stop a break down the Glasgow left, but then switches off and stands at the short side marking no one – leaving a fairly simple overlap when Glasgow shift it right.

    The game was really entertaining so well done to those involved – but it would be good to see a tougher defensive mentality from some players.

  4. Agreed sceptic9 last weeks Irish Derby ends 54-42 or something stupid and is clearly superior this week its 13-6 and clearly superior. Give it a rest Morrison.

  5. Agreed sceptic9 last weeks Irish Derby ends 54-42 or something stupid and is clearly superior this week its 13-6 and clearly superior. Give it a rest Morrison.

  6. and many of those Irish will be facing scotland in the 6N. How many? The IRFU had a squad training week in the run up to this weekend and forced 20 players to sit out the Munster-Leinster match. Any decent journo knows this, but it doesn’t suit the agenda here.

    Honestly The Offside Line is a great website but Morrison’s constant agenda driven whinging will lose readers and support

  7. It is up to the Assistant referees to monitor offside, not the referee! Unfortunately, that message has not been passed on by the SRU at all levels of the game.

  8. excellent article Iain. I would also respectfully take issue with Matt’s “entertainment is the name of the game” argument. Being entertaining must come second to the result at all levels of the game after minis and especially at the elite level. Richard Cockerill has the right mindset for me. Wish it would rub off quicker on some of our elite players.

    • If I’m paying £20 for an Edinburgh game or upwards of £50 for a Scotland game, I expect to be entertained. I’d rather see “my”team lose 49-50 than win 3-0
      Would you prefer we went back to Frank Haddens zero-risk of just blooter the ball and hope their FB drops it?

  9. Glasgow have went from formidable to ordinary in the space of a year, Edinburgh’s steady rise continues.

    As much as Hasting’s is young, he isn’t a game changer and some of his choices are pretty questionable. Almost seems like he’s trying too hard. Hopefully Glasgow steady the ship, this season is looking close to a write off. Congratulations to Edinburgh, though. Looking pretty good for them.

  10. Of course Morry, it could be that our players have bought into the Gregor Townsend/Brazilian football mind set: “OK, you score three times, we’ll score four.”

    It might offend the purists, but, it will keep the fans entertained. And isn’t entertainment the name of the game?

    • ah, so last week according to Morry it was turgid, this week plenty of tries and its rubbish defence. What a moaning minnie you are.
      There were defensive errors, but why didn’t you applaud the great defence from both teams last week, instead calling it turgid stuff? Because you have an Everest sized chip on your shoulder, and an aye been moaner.

Comments are closed.